QUOTE(Theoriser @ Oct 30 2006, 10:05 PM) [snapback]993392[/snapback]
I saw this video when it first came out as well, and I liked it too. I thought that Michael Gambon was hilarious, even thought I don't like his portrayal of Dumbledore at all. To me, this video shows that he could be a really great Dumbledore; you can see the twinkle in his eyes and the sense of humour he has, but he just doesn't bother to do the role properly. Oh well, it's a funny video.
I don't blame Gambon for the portrayal, I like him & he's certainly an entertaining guy. It's the director who has the final say. Gambon will play the role how he's directed to play it. I think Mike Newell is responsible for 'Angry Dumbledore' not Gambon. He's also responsible, incidently, for 'Angry Fred & George' which I don't usually see other people mentioning, even though their fight, after trying to put their names in the Goblet, is just as out of character as Dumbledore's outburst. In the book they burst out laughing!
I agree with you that Gambon has the potential to be a great Dumbledore if he was allowed &/or encouraged to 'twinkle' the way he does here. I think he showed that potential in PoA. At least the OotP director, unlike Newell has read all the books, so maybe...
Maybe though, if people watch this they'll realise he's not treating HP any differently to his other roles, at least he read the script, unlike for Gosford Park apparently!