Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Fan Art Icontest Icon Discussion
Harry Potter discussion forum for movies, books, and more! - The Leaky Lounge > HP-Related Discussion: Diagon Alley > Leaky Sites: Cauldron's Corner > The Leaky Galleries > Leaky Fan Art Gallery Forum
Hagiographer13
The results from the first TLC FanArt Gallery Icontest are up and the second one is in full swing. thumbup.gif

The first contest results were as follows --
QUOTE
Final Voting:
[ 4 ] ** [9.09%]
[ 4 ] ** [9.09%]
[ 6 ] ** [13.64%]
[ 7 ] ** [15.91%]
[ 0 ] ** [0.00%]
[ 4 ] ** [9.09%]
[ 2 ] ** [4.55%]
[ 7 ] ** [15.91%]
[ 8 ] ** [18.18%]
[ 2 ] ** [4.55%]

You can see the winning Icons featuring the wonderful art of last month's Featured FanArtist, the one-and-only glockgal , right here.

Feel free to use this thread to discuss the past winners of the FanArt Icontests. However, do not discuss the current contest entries until after the contest closes. smile.gif

BTW, this is the cool contest badge that winners will get to sport on their profile sidebars --
Hagiographer13
I decided it would be easier to discuss the winners if they were posted here too. tongue.gif

QUOTE
Fan Art Icontest Challenge 01: Glockgal
First Place by evilpudseybear


Second Place: (Tie)
by KimmyBlair


& by evilpudseybear



Third Place by Alantie_el


Guest Judge Glockgal's Choice (by KimmyBlair):

I really liked the added background to the Artist's Choice--very cool!
VoodooPadfoot
Well done to all of you, they're all superb. I have to say that Third Place was actually my favourite it is just so beautiful and really portray's Sirius' feelings at that pinacle point of his life.
JeffHpFan
Wow, am I stupid! I just realized that the first and judges choice were the same original picture! doh.gif
I love how Kimmy added that background in, and I agree with VoodooPadfoot that I enjoyed the third place entry as well.
evilpudseybear
I really liked KimmyBlair's 2nd place one, the way it's been cropped is really nice and the font is great too biggrin.gif
KimmyBlair
Fan Art Icontest Challenge 02: sulkyskrewt
First Place: (tie)
by: Rotae

& by blue4t


Second Place: (Tie)
by Iheartprofessorsnape

& by JeffHpFan


Third Place by yellowpepper2311


Guest Judge sulkyskrewt's Choices (i can't blame her for not being able to pick only one!)
yellowpepper2311 & Rotae for their two icons above.



The Full Results:
Please vote for your favorite icon
[ 8 ] ** [17.78%]
[ 1 ] ** [2.22%]
[ 0 ] ** [0.00%]
[ 1 ] ** [2.22%]
[ 1 ] ** [2.22%]
[ 5 ] ** [11.11%]
[ 0 ] ** [0.00%]
[ 2 ] ** [4.44%]
[ 4 ] ** [8.89%]
[ 1 ] ** [2.22%]
[ 2 ] ** [4.44%]
[ 2 ] ** [4.44%]
[ 3 ] ** [6.67%]
[ 5 ] ** [11.11%]
[ 0 ] ** [0.00%]
[ 1 ] ** [2.22%]
[ 1 ] ** [2.22%]
[ 8 ] ** [17.78%]
phoenix call
Theses are always really good, i wouldnt have known which to vote for.
~Mrs.Brisby~
Maybe it's just my computer but none of the icons are showing up. They're all little red X's.
Hagiographer13
QUOTE(~Mrs.Brisby~ @ Jun 17 2008, 09:10 AM) *
Maybe it's just my computer but none of the icons are showing up. They're all little red X's.

What browser are you using? Several folks using Internet Explorer reported similar problems.

Either way, I recommend clearing your bowser cache and restarting the browser to see if that fixes the problem. type.gif Good luck!
blue4t
All I want to say is this a very awesome group of icons. Everyone did a great job!
tonksgirl
oh no, cant see the images sad.gif and i have safari so not the internet explorer problem. sad.gif

~Mrs.Brisby~
QUOTE(Hagiographer13 @ Jun 17 2008, 03:37 PM) *
QUOTE(~Mrs.Brisby~ @ Jun 17 2008, 09:10 AM) *
Maybe it's just my computer but none of the icons are showing up. They're all little red X's.

What browser are you using? Several folks using Internet Explorer reported similar problems.

Either way, I recommend clearing your bowser cache and restarting the browser to see if that fixes the problem. type.gif Good luck!

Well I tried it on IE and AOL and neither worked - but they're showing up fine on my other computer (using IE). smile.gif Thanks for the tip though! I'll try it when I get a chance.

All I can say about the icons is WOW! Great job everyone! biggrin.gif
ravenclaw1028
The icons are also not showing up on my computer, and I am using firefox sad.gif

EDIT: yay! they are working
KimmyBlair
We are working on this issue guys... If you can not currently view the images please try another browser, or computer (if you can).

If not we are working on an alternative! Hopefully we will have something soon.

- Kim
KimmyBlair
Lets see if this works



with a link here if you can't view the image. (I suggest that you view the full sized image if you are going to use this image to vote. The smaller version in this post will not display the icons at the optimal resolution which should be used for viewing the icons properly.)

That is all of the images in the poll above. Numbers are ABOVE the icons so keep that in mind when voting!

Can everyone see this image? If you are one of the people who posted they could not see the images in the poll, please let me know if this works instead!
evilpudseybear
Wow! They're all brilliant! That was a really hard choice, I really love several of them!
phoenix call
Wow, they are all so good smile.gif I found it so hard to choose.
KimmyBlair
As voting is now done for Fan Art icontest challenge #2, please feel free to discuss the icons! Results can be found here, and all the icons may be found
Just a reminder of all the icons submitted!
KimmyBlair
As voting is now done for Fan Art icontest challenge #3, please feel free to discuss the icons! Results can be found here, and all the icons may be found
Just a reminder of all the icons submitted!

kendra.dumbledore
Wow! These are all so fantastic! And the artwork is so great! Nice job everyone. biggrin.gif
SnapesSister
These are all great! It was hard to choose!
Apple
The decision was hard this week. I like the fact that most people chose a picture of Ron!
I wish I could have voted for more than one as I had three favourites. We'll just have to see if those three win.
KimmyBlair
I agree with all of the people who said how hard it was to vote! I was so excited about the turnout, both quality wise, and number wise. A bit thank you to everyone who participated!
Hagiographer13
I wanted to share with the iconers and fans here what our FanArtist for these avatars, Lillywmw, had to say as she prepares to choose her favourite for the "Artist's Choice Award" --
QUOTE(Lillwmw)
I´m just so sad to have to choice only one of so many wonderful works you have there on the challenge!
I love every single one!

And I quite agree: wonderful work everyone, it's a tough choice to make! clap.gif
MJLeakyCon
All the avatars are gorgeous, because the artist's vision of the characters is just so pure and amazing. What a fun challenge! Good luck to all the participants!
lirene
All of the images are simply fantastic woohoo.gif and I had a very difficult time voting, but the one I chose is simply breathtaking! And the colors are amazing!
JeffHpFan
I have to say, the avatars for this contest were great! It was really hard choosing my favorite. I loved the Judge's Choice icon by Hagiographer13, it was one of my favorites.

Really good job to everyone who participated.
KimmyBlair
Please vote for your favorite icon using slytherinfiend's great artwork. Please do not vote for yourself, or as others to vote for you. As always here is the preview table if you have trouble viewing the icons above.



Remember, do not say which icon is your favorite until the results have been posted! Thanks!
libbysmom
We have another crop of great icons! It really is difficult to choose. Of course, using slytherinfiend's artwork is always a great jumping off point as well wink.gif Well done everyone!
Hagiographer13
What libbysmom said! Really good stuff, good luck to all!
JeffHpFan
Wow, all the icons are amazing! Some stiff competition!
Awesome job on the icons, people! towel.gif
kendra.dumbledore
It's funny because there are only 6 icons yet it is so tough to choose. Nice job everyone. smile.gif
Hagiographer13
Just a reminder that the voting for this contest closes Sunday night, August 24, at midnight. smile.gif

Have YOU voted yet?
KimmyBlair
Well the results for challenge #4 have been posted up here so you can now discuss your favorite icons!

As a reminder here were all the entries

KimmyBlair
Another great week of icons based on the great art of cambryn. Please as always pick one icon, and make sure to not pick your own icon, or have others vote for you.

Here is the regular preview of the icons:

Apple
As usual, a wonderful set of icons! Well done everyone.
But now you have given me the hard choice of picking just one!
KimmyBlair
QUOTE(Apple @ Sep 16 2008, 04:24 AM) *
As usual, a wonderful set of icons! Well done everyone.
But now you have given me the hard choice of picking just one!

I second that! I sat there looking at the icons for a really long time before picking one! I think I just about picked each one at one point before finally submitting my final choice!
JeffHpFan
I just wanted to say that I absolutely LOVED Kimmyblair's icon entry. I think it should have won the contest, I loved it so much!
KimmyBlair
Sorry the poll is so late this week! The internet gods just did not want me posting, and kept thwarting me at every turn, however it's up now!

As always pick your favorite icon. Do not vote for yourself or ask others to vote for you as this will get you disqualified.

The cheat sheet of icons:


Voting will be up until Monday the 21st at 11:59 EST

Please do not post which specific icon you are voting for! Thank you!
JeffHpFan
Some fabulous icons this week! I'm glad the poll's up-- it was a hard choice!
EducationalDecreeNo23
I voted for 003
Deathly Hallower
Wow, there are some amazing icons this week! Great job to everyone who entered.
SnapesSister
Nice work everyone, tough decision to make here!
KimmyBlair
Now that the winners have been posted up here it's time to discuss the icons! A reminder of the icons here:



based on the great art of MikeyBooch!

I found it very interesting that the four winning icons used two of the same pieces of art! Even though they did use the same art they were both interpreted in different ways, which I found great!
JeffHpFan
QUOTE(KimmyBlair @ Oct 21 2008, 01:26 PM) *
I found it very interesting that the four winning icons used two of the same pieces of art! Even though they did use the same art they were both interpreted in different ways, which I found great!

I did two! It's very interesting! I must say that I loved your icon, KimmyBlair. If it was my choice, even though I am biased, I would have chosen yours to win, so I was actually surprised by the results...
KimmyBlair
QUOTE(JeffHpFan @ Oct 21 2008, 04:20 PM) *
I did two! It's very interesting! I must say that I loved your icon, KimmyBlair. If it was my choice, even though I am biased, I would have chosen yours to win, so I was actually surprised by the results...

Thank you for the compliment!

On the same note as the winning icons using the same three pieces of art, I noticed that the three icons using the snitch all had borders around them! That really shows that great minds think alike!
kendra.dumbledore
Kim, and Jeff I LOVED your icons! Kim the background on yours is AMAZING and I really wish that I could do stuff like that but I have know idea how! Jeff I love how you (and Kim too) can make borders look good. I can never get them to look right! smile.gif Oh and Jeff I love the brush that you used for the iHarry icon. I like it alot!
KimmyBlair
Please vote for your favorite icon. Do not vote for yourself, or ask others to vote for you.

Preview:


Please do not talk about which icon you voted for.

kendra.dumbledore
Wow! There are some great icons here. smile.gif Nice job everyone.
KimmyBlair
Now that the winners have been posted up here it's time to discuss the icons! A reminder of the icons here:

Preview:


Which icon was your favorite, and why?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.
CommunitySEO 1.1.4 P1 © 2008  IPB SEO Module