Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

Harry Potter discussion forum for movies, books, and more! - The Leaky Lounge _ Non-HP Books: Waxflatter's Books _ The Wheel of Time Series

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 11 2009, 02:24 PM

From the last post in http://www.leakylounge.com/Wheel-Time-Series-t28285.html&st=490#entry1782423:

QUOTE(Shard @ May 11 2009, 01:10 PM) *
Yeah its been a little over 2 years plus some months. So the boys are about 20-21, Eggy is apparently 18, Elyane is I think 18 but not sure. Basically they are all very young.

Before he got the Dagger and met the Finn's Mat was exhibting signs of having Old Tongue knowledge though any memories I think were more like feelings or something. I think Mat was always set up to be a Master of Battles sort of character.

Posted by: Shard May 11 2009, 07:08 PM

Has anyone read the exerpt of what will be on the cover?

A Memory of Light was partially finished by Robert Jordan before his untimely passing in 2007. Brandon Sanderson, New York Times bestselling author of the Mistborn books, was chosen by Jordan’s editor—his wife, Harriet McDougal—to complete the final book. The scope and size of the novel was such that it can not be contained in a single volume, and so Tor proudly presents A Memory of Light: Gathering Clouds as the first in a short sequence of novels that will complete the struggle against the Shadow, bringing to a close a journey begun almost twenty years ago and marking the conclusion of the Wheel of Time, the preeminent fantasy epic of our era.

QUOTE
In this epic novel, Robert Jordan’s international bestselling series begins its dramatic conclusion. Rand al’Thor, the Dragon Reborn, struggles to unite a fractured network of kingdoms and alliances in preparation for the Last Battle. As he attempts to halt the Seanchan encroachment northward—wishing he could form at least a temporary truce with the invaders—his allies work in desperation to forestall the shadow that seems to be growing within the heart of the Dragon Reborn himself.
Egwene al’Vere, the Amyrlin Seat of the rebel Aes Sedai, is a captive of the White Tower and subject to the whims of their tyrannical leader. As days tick toward the Seanchan attack she knows is imminent, Egwene works to hold together the disparate factions of Aes Sedai while providing leadership in the face of increasing uncertainty and despair. Her fight will prove the mettle of the Aes Sedai, and her conflict will decide the future of the White Tower—and therefore the world itself.

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 12 2009, 12:36 PM

Whoa! That's great to know, Shard!

I was wondering when the Seachan attacking the White Tower would take place. I hadn't thought it would be this early. Somehow I figured with Tuon heading back to take control in the homeland that she'd take her troops with her. But it makes sense for them to all eventually come under Rand. Considering how they feel about women touching the One Power, imagine what they'll think of Rand.

We've had how many of the main characters have contact with the Seanchan? Nynaeve and Elayne (and Mat) have met that one Seanchan who was traveling with the circus. Surely she'll be brought back. Perrin worked with the Seanchan to get Faile back. Mat is now married to the Seanchan Empress. ponder.gif Anybody else?

Posted by: Shard May 12 2009, 06:48 PM

I think Galad may have had to fight them at one point in getting all those Whitecloaks out of Amadica.

I can't wait to see Rand meet with Perrin and Mat and learn about the dealings they have had with the Seachan. Mat marrying the Empress of them no less!

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 12 2009, 10:19 PM

Good point about Galad. I keep forgetting him, but he must have something to do besides be Rand's unknown half brother. That still makes me smile that Elayne and Rand (unrelated) have the same half brother. lol.gif

I was just listening to the part where Tom goes after the Half Man to save Rand and Mat. When you think about it, he's really grown a lot himself. He was a bit like Mat at first not wanting to get involved and yet always getting involved, all the while denying it. While what happened to his nephew Owen was the initial motivation to help the boys, Tom seemed to get very close to Moiraine--enough that he's going to be one of the ones to go and get her back from the dead. That's pretty serious dedication for someone who didn't trust Aes Sedai at all in the beginning (though willing to accept their help).

Posted by: Shard May 13 2009, 06:06 AM

Well Galad's purpose so far seems to be leading the WC contingent and for Rand as well. I am really wanting to see a scene where Galad explains how he got the two most rabid dogs to heel and agree to fight FOR the Dragon.

Thom seems like one of those characters that grumbles about the trouble they keep getting mixed in. I think it's just built up for Thom over the books to the point where he thinks it's just the right thing to do.

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 14 2009, 03:10 PM

I just reached the part where Rand first meets Loial, and it reminded me that the Seanchan have Ogier warriors. That must mean there are steddings in Seanchan. For some reason I'd just always assumed the steddings were just on the main continent.

Something else I didn't pay attention to once I was in the later books, was that Morgase already had problems with her subjects before Rahvin seduced her and changed how she ruled.

Posted by: Shard May 15 2009, 05:25 AM

Yeah the Ogier in Seachan are called the Gardener's and they tend to like using Axes. There alot less nicer then then Randland Ogier, they don't have the longing and so don't need the Stedding's as much if at all.

Any problems with Morgase's rule though were minor until Rahvin aka Gabril came along.

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 16 2009, 10:15 AM

Well, I just found it interesting that they also had Ogier. Makes me wonder if they took some with them, captured them on their way, or if there were Ogier where they set up their empire. And what will they think when they see their brethren?

In the book, I'm at the point where the group is in Shienar preparing to go into the Blight, and I was particularly taken with how everyone called Lan Dai Shan (battle lord) and vehemently wanted him to take up his and fly the Golden Crane again. It's making me really excited to see the size of the army that ends up coming to him as he makes that little trek Nynaeve set him on. devil.gif

But I also remembered that Agelmar's wife is a darkfriend, and I cannot remember if she was ever caught or could still play a role.

Posted by: Shard May 16 2009, 11:25 PM

They were always there, they had ready access to the steddings so they never went through the Longing. They just evolved into colder, meaner and darker versions of the Randland variety.

I don't remember a wife, I know he had a sister I think... It's been awhile..

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 17 2009, 06:16 AM

You're right about no wife--it's his sister. I hadn't gotten to that part of the book yet when I posted previously. But I'm wondering if we're done with her yet or I've just forgotten--like what happened with Rand's heron-marked sword.

Posted by: Shard May 17 2009, 10:22 AM

Well as for the Heron Marked sword it's not so much forgotten but done with. The sword was destroyed down to the hilt, what further use did Rand have for it?

I'm frankly dissapointed with Agelmar in general, I really expected him to do and say more in defense of Rand and it seems like he's just taking a back seat or something. I think at the time I read about Agelmar's sister I thought her being a DF was a lie or red herring. Afterall it was Ingtar who let Padan Fain in and it was Liandrain who freed him. So I don't think his sister was actually a DF.

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 29 2009, 09:25 AM

Yes, once Rand had declared I also expected to hear something from Agelmar.

I'm on the second book now, and I'm curious about something Verin said. You know how Moiraine said to Egwene that someday she could even be the Amyrlin. When Verin was talking with Nynaeve, she started to say something about how strong the two women wilders were and was talking about how far they could go. She started to say something like Nynaeve especially could . . . and Verin broke off. It made me curious if Aes Sedai see power differently or this was a hint that Nynaeve could go to the top (because Egwene will die, since she's the Amyrlin?).

But I kind of feel that Nynaeve has a new focus since she's married Lan, and I'm really hoping he will bring his kingdom back.

ETA: I got to the part in The Great Hunt where Min and Egwene first meet. Elayne mentions that Min "saw" that Elayne would have to share her husband with two other women. Hmmm . . . Elayne and Rand haven't married yet. Does this bode well for Rand surviving, since I'm not sure there'd be time before the end for them to get together and wed? Of course, if we're looking at 3 more books with about 300,000 pages each who knows what could happen! huh.gif

Posted by: Shard May 30 2009, 10:58 AM

Well the Aes Sedai do have that whole defering to people who have more Power then others. However they could have meant that Nynaeve could be Amyrlin. I don't think Egwene will be dying though. It's possible that if Lan brings back Malkier that Nyn will be it's queen along with Lan being the king of it.

Posted by: Seven of Nine May 30 2009, 12:57 PM

Yes, I'm really hoping that happens.

And that brings up something else that I wondered about today, when I got to the part where Rand finds Thom alive. Thom inquired if Moiraine was with Rand, and when Rand said she was not, Thom was disappointed and started to say that she was a fine woman and then broke off. Now the storylines have been leading to more and more Aes Sedai connecting with men. We've already got Nynaeve and Lan married, then there's that fire going between Siuan and Gareth Bryne. Plus Leane is always interested in men now. We have Egwene probably getting together with Gawyn, and of course Elayne as a Queen needs to have a hubby. So, with Moiraine asking Thom to come and bring her back from the "dead" could there end up being more between them later?

Posted by: Shard May 30 2009, 05:32 PM

Yes there definatly is, there was a scene where Moraine told Nynaeve, Egwene and I think Elayne that she knew the face of the man she would marry better then any of those three knew theirs. Which was interesting since by that point we have confirmation of who all three are into, though I think Egwene/Gawyn may not have been as certain. Though we did know Nyn/Lan and Elyane/Rand.

Yes I always thought the Aes Sedai not getting married and having children was silly. I mean I am sure they don't all want to do so or have to but it would have been good if more did then not. The Randland world is stepping closer to healing that gap the Taint had caused between men and women.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 1 2009, 08:05 PM

Something I totally forgot about was Egwene's affinity for identifying metals--Earth. It's something that men were especially strong at. That has to be important for something coming or why even mention it?

ETA: I'm at the part in GH where Mat blows the horn and the Heroes of the Horn. Some impressions: They mention Gaidal Cain (Brigitte's love). If he comes out of the horn, doesn't that mean he can't be alive again yet? So if it's only been a couple of years between EotW and KoD, that's not enough time, right? But the WoT Encyclopedia says he disappears from Tel'aran'rhiod and has been reborn. So he has been reborn, but I don't think he's old enough to be that kid Mat takes under his wing. ponder.gif

Also, isn't it interesting that Artur Hawkwing is among the Heroes of the Horn who oust his descendants from Falma?

Oh, and I've wondered for a while--if Egwene can't make cuendillar, why couldn't she fix the seals on the Dark One's prison?

Hmmm . . . and Uno says to Rand that when the Dragon is reborn he will break all oaths. If that's true, could it also be oaths made with the Aes Sedai oath rod?

I'm also curious about how Lan's cousin and Rand's uncle are both facets of Slayer.

Posted by: Shard Jun 2 2009, 09:54 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Jun 1 2009, 09:05 PM) *
Something I totally forgot about was Egwene's affinity for identifying metals--Earth. It's something that men were especially strong at. That has to be important for something coming or why even mention it?


It's only important insofar as what the Seachan were going to use her for. I don't think there is any further importance really, finding metal ores in the ground doesn't seem important to the plot. Only just highlighted what the Seachan were going to exploit her for.

QUOTE
ETA: I'm at the part in GH where Mat blows the horn and the Heroes of the Horn. Some impressions: They mention Gaidal Cain (Brigitte's love). If he comes out of the horn, doesn't that mean he can't be alive again yet? So if it's only been a couple of years between EotW and KoD, that's not enough time, right? But the WoT Encyclopedia says he disappears from Tel'aran'rhiod and has been reborn. So he has been reborn, but I don't think he's old enough to be that kid Mat takes under his wing. ponder.gif


Pretty sure RJ said no to Gaidal Cain = Olver. Said that there wasn't enough time and that it doesn't flow backwards, etc. Though I always thought it was an interesting idea.

QUOTE
Also, isn't it interesting that Artur Hawkwing is among the Heroes of the Horn who oust his descendants from Falma?


Ironic I think is what it is. They fight to reclaim land in Hawkwing's name and he fights to stop them.

QUOTE
Oh, and I've wondered for a while--if Egwene can't make cuendillar, why couldn't she fix the seals on the Dark One's prison?


She can make cuendillar, but I think the seals need to be broken and the bore made as if it had never been. The patch just isn't good enough, it allowed the DO to influence and touch the world, limited but he still did touch it.

QUOTE
Hmmm . . . and Uno says to Rand that when the Dragon is reborn he will break all oaths. If that's true, could it also be oaths made with the Aes Sedai oath rod?


I think it's figurative, they chose to break their oath and swear new ones to Rand. The Aes Sedai are still sworn by the Oath Rod but they can still swear new ones to Rand.

QUOTE
I'm also curious about how Lan's cousin and Rand's uncle are both facets of Slayer.


Probably merged in T'A'R. It is strange though .

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Jun 2 2009, 10:31 PM

My hubby is almost on book 8, so he's almost letting me start reading the series again. He thinks that if he's that far ahead I won't overtake him this time like I usually do.

I was thinking that the strength in earth may be important to the making of Cuendillar. I dunno, they change iron into it, right? Or some metal anyway, so I always assumed that it was the aes sedai who were strong in earth that made it, and that's why it had been a dying art. Since in the Age of Legends it was men who mostly had strength in that power, and the women slowly lost the knowledge because it wasn't something they were generally good at.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 2 2009, 10:39 PM

Good point, Harry's Horntail!

I had a typo earlier when I said Egwene couldn't make cuendillar--I meant that she could. And that would make sense if she's very powerful, and she's powerful with Earth which men were the strongest in.

Maybe they will be able to finally defeat the Dark One by using a man AND a woman, and it will keep this time. Perhaps that's where things went wrong before--only the men were involved in locking the Dark One in his prison.

There's such a push in the books for men and women to begin working together again, I think it's possible.

Dang but I'm excited!

Posted by: Shard Jun 3 2009, 12:02 PM

That may make sense then strength in earth can help in making Cuendillar, so perhaps that's a good reason to bring up that Egwene is good with Earth.

Moriane did have a speech in tEotW to Egwene that the Men used Earth and Fire more powerfully and Women had Wind and Water. She also went on to say that didn't mean the men had better abilities, just that they were more adept at those two powers and women at the other two. The powers balance themselves just like they do in HP.

I agree 7of9 I think both the halves of the One Power are needed, we'll never know what the result would have been had the women gone with Lews Therin. However I was very excited as well that Saidin got cleansed and Men would once again be able to channel without going insane.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 3 2009, 01:20 PM

Except for poor Rand with someone else in his head who's nuts and wants to kill everyone. Funny. It actually kind of reminds me of Zane in the Mistborn series the way Rand and Lews Therin talk.

I must confess that part depresses me, because I really like Rand. I hate to see him brutalized like he is as he goes to what he's sure will be his death.

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Jun 3 2009, 01:40 PM

Rand's situation always saddens me. He came so far from that naive, sweet young boy and he cleansed the taint basically for the benefit of all the others around him. He himself gets no benefit from it because Lews Therin seems to be another kind of crazy altogether. I really hope he can stop being so hard, and that at least some of his 'building up' projects make it through. I love that he wants to do something, leave something good in his wake, so I hope that actually works.

And it is so sad that he lives this life with certain knowledge that he will die. Harry lives with that for half an hour, poor Rand is stuck with it for years. I do hope he's wrong, though. That kid has sacrificed so much already, it would be awful to see him lose his life too.

Posted by: Shard Jun 4 2009, 10:21 AM

And I think that is *exactly* what Robert Jordan wants us to feel for Rand, that he has given so much and gets so little in return. At least so far he has gotten so little, I think there is some hope that he will survive or be rewarded. Rand has the weight of the world on his shoulders and that is a heavy burden.

Yeah I think the Taint has done a certain amount of Damage to various male channelers, the good of the Cleansing is that there will be no further damage. However the existing damage is still there. The thing is that the current mental damages may be fixable now the corrupting influence of the Taint is gone.

It's a shame that Rand sees being human as being weak, Harry sorta had that problem as well more with the crying then the laughing though.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 4 2009, 01:05 PM

I'm beginning The Dragon Reborn, and I totally forgot that one of the signs of the Dragon says he "shall bind the nine moons to serve him." Since Gathering Storm appears to be dealing (at least in part) with the assault by the Seanchan on the White Tower, perhaps this is when it will happen.

Posted by: Shard Jun 4 2009, 05:28 PM

*heh* I think the binding the Nine Moons to him happened when Mat said "She is my wife, Toun is my wife, the bloody Daughter of the Nine Moons is my wife" lol. He had no idea what he was getting into by saying that.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 4 2009, 05:38 PM

But Tuon is pretty independent, and she doesn't exactly take Mat seriously enough yet. Mat even commented to her before she left with that guy who came for her that he hoped he didn't have to face her in battle. Interesting marriage.

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Jun 4 2009, 08:26 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Jun 4 2009, 05:38 PM) *
But Tuon is pretty independent, and she doesn't exactly take Mat seriously enough yet. Mat even commented to her before she left with that guy who came for her that he hoped he didn't have to face her in battle. Interesting marriage.


But that is exactly why they will be perfect for each other, neither would have chosen the other for a companion and yet they compliment each other's strengths and balance their weaknesses.

A little off-topic, Shard and Seven of Nine you both amaze me with the depth of your recall of the series. As often as I have re-read this series (alot!), you both blow me away. And SoN, I love your new siggy! tongue.gif

Posted by: Shard Jun 4 2009, 08:52 PM

Yeah I've read the WoT series so many times I've lost count I really don't know what it is but the first half would be quite a bit higher then the later half. I think that WoT is really becoming my all time favorite series really, yes even more then HP. ohmy.gif Still love my HP though so don't hold it against me too much.

And as for Toun I didn't mean it was in completion but it certainly started down that road. Mat slowly fits more and more of her Signs that she was looking for in him.

Sometimes I wonder how events would have brought these two together if he didn't go into the Finn door in Tear. I suppose he was always going to do that, since he needed answers.

The thing I am eager to see is what will happen with the Forsaken in the next book. Semi is captured, The BA hunters are getting closer to finding Messana, Graendal may come under fire in Arad Doman.


Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 6 2009, 12:00 PM

QUOTE(MysteryloverAnne @ Jun 4 2009, 07:26 PM) *
And SoN, I love your new siggy! tongue.gif

Thanks. That line really struck me when I was listening to Michael Kramer do that chapter with the portal. He reads the books so well, and that dang Forsaken just ticked me off the way he kept saying that! lol.gif

I'm reading tDR and a couple of things struck me this morning. One deals the the Horn of Valere. They kept saying that they had to get it away from Fain and his Darkfriends because the Heroes of the Horn would follow whoever blew it. Yet when Mat blew it and Artur Hawkwing and the others came, they wouldn't ride until Rand raised the Dragon Banner. Doesn't that appear to be a contradiction?

The other thing deals with what I think will be an upcoming storyline. The book cover for Gathering Storm talks about Rand's struggle with his sanity (who wouldn't struggle with a nutter like Lews Therin in his head). But as I was at the part in tDR where Egwene is being raised to Accepted, her second test (they all deal with Rand, so that says a lot about how much they are linked) dealt with Rand pleading with her to kill him with her blade (he saw her doing this in one of those alternate realities). Rand said that the madness made it harder for him to hold onto himself and the others would be able to turn him.

Another thing that just occurred to me was Verin telling Egwene when she gave her the dream Ter'Angreal that the Dark One was bound in all the alternate realities. If he is released in one, he will be released in them all. dry.gif

Posted by: Shard Jun 6 2009, 08:18 PM

The Aes Sedai have been known to make mistakes, they clearly didn't realize the importance of having the Banner there when the Horn was blown.

I think Rand has a chance to be healed now of his madness, now that the Taint is gone. I think Nynaeve can probably help but Rand is going to have to do some of it the old fashioned way (ie no magic) but with Laughter and Tears.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 9 2009, 01:21 PM

Well, I hope you're right, Shard. I'm afraid that the only time Rand will finally be healed is when Lews Therin is gone.

Here's something I was thinking about. I love Moiraine's character, but she creates some of her own problems. I'm thinking here especially of just before she and Lanfear "die" when she's finally able to teach Rand after practically begging him to let her share what she knows. Some of that she set up herself. She does the same things with Perrin. She tells the boys to let her know if they have any dreams. When Perrin (in tDR) tells her about his wolf dream and seeing Lanfear, Moiraine scares the crap out of him. That's hardly the way to encourage him to keep confiding in her.

I'm sorry. The arrogance of the women in these books just bugs.

Posted by: Shard Jun 9 2009, 03:04 PM

Yeah I think they will need to deal with Lews and Moridin in his head, Rand has it rough. Don't know how much of that will be explored in the next book.

The arrogance is pretty bad at times some worse then others. Probably why I like Min and Birgitte so much. They really do think very little of men at times it seems.

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Jun 9 2009, 04:04 PM

QUOTE(Shard @ Jun 10 2009, 08:04 AM) *
The arrogance is pretty bad at times some worse then others. Probably why I like Min and Birgitte so much. They really do think very little of men at times it seems.

I reckon it's a mutual thing. The women think very little of the men at times and the men think little of the women at times. Both sides infuriate me with their attitudes to each other. I hope that one of the things they learn is to respect each other's strong points rather than belittle the weaknesses.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 9 2009, 09:08 PM

Well, one of the things that really bugs me is in this book (tDR), I think. Mat goes through great lengths to warn the three women and jeopardizes his life to help save them in Tear. They happen to have done pretty well getting themselves out of being captured by the Black Adjah and are scandalized when Mat suggests they might need rescuing. But they didn't act that way when Ruarc and the other Aiel help them get away from the river brigands who were going to sell them to the Myrdraal. Whatever happened to it's the thought that counts? Really, that just shows, to me anyway, their own insecurity.

But here's a thought that came to me tonight. What does it take to really be turned to the shadow? It seems like power and glory are major motivators among Dark Friends (and the Forsaken as well). Faile decides to stick with Perrin, Lan, Loial, and Moiraine because she's sure that what is happening to them will be a story told through the ages--and she wants a part of it. That just seems to run in line too much with what Lanfear keeps trying to use on Rand. It just made me wonder if we have some people in our groups that we are sure are loyal to the Light (and Rand) that could be turned.

Posted by: Shard Jun 9 2009, 10:42 PM

Actually they DID need Mat's help getting out. They took out the BA sure, but the door was still locked. All it would have taken was one of the MANY Forsaken runing around at the time to find them locked up in there. Or Slayer or some really determined Trollocs.

Though really the point is that their Pride is so great that to be rescued by Mat is just intolerable. I just loved in aCoS when Brigitte and Aviendha made the girls apologize. To add insult to injury Mat forgot to mention the Forsaken were in Tear and Elayne had let slip that one of them had been there. Really it was more like 3 or 4 Forsaken where there, not just one. Lanfear, Bel'la, Ishy; not to mention other Forsaken may have at least been watching. I don't know if Sammy and/or Graendal or Semi were there but there are implications that they had least sent the Trollocs in.

Really it just astounds me that they have so little respect for Mat.

Faile I think is a great example of a character that is on the side of the Light but not for the reason of "I want to help Rand". Unlike in Harry Potter the majority of the cast doesn't necessarily care about Rand or his fight. There have been times where Faile really seemed to just want to stay in Emond's Field and forget about the rest of the world so long as she was with Perrin. I don't know if she cares about Glory on the same level Lanfear did though.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 11 2009, 08:39 AM

Yes, Shard, that's the scene that really bugged me. You know, the more times I read the series, the more I like Mat. I've always liked him, but I see more the true depth of his character.

Something struck me this morning as I was listening to tDR. I'm at the part where Mat and Juilan have met up to go into the Stone after the girls. The girls are terrified that with 13 Aes Sedai there all that would be needed to turn them to the dark side would be 13 Myrdraal. Earlier when Moiraine is asking Loial about Be'lal. From the http://www.encyclopaedia-wot.org/ it says:
Be'lal and Lews Therin are allies for a time during the War of Power. Be'lal is a leader in the fight against the Dark One before he forsakes the Light.

That made me wonder about the whole turning thing. Did Be'lal forsake the light on his own or could he have been turned? And could someone who has been turned like this be turned back?

This is a theme that seems to be referred to much less in the later books, but I wonder if it could come back.

Posted by: Shard Jun 12 2009, 06:29 PM

It is possible that one or more Forsaken were turned to the Dark Side. It would sure be nice to have examples of this happening in the story since RJ mentioned it so long ago. It sounds like a one way ticket though, once they go Dark there is no going back.

I think Mat is probably one of the most liked characters. He's closer to being the "joe normal" then Perrin and Rand, though he does get rather extrodinary with his uncanny Luck.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 13 2009, 04:57 PM

I got to the part in tSR where Mat (and Rand and Moiraine) went through the Ter'Angreal in Tear. I can't believe the blew off the part where Mat is told that he will give up half the Light to save the Light. What?

And what's this connection of the Aelfinn and Eelfinn with that game of snakes and foxes? Isn't Moiraine with them?

Oooo, and something I didn't notice before either. Both of those snake & fox creatures in the Ter'Angreals ask if Mat has followed the agreement, saying something about not bringing metals, weapons, or musical instruments. Curious isn't it that Moiraine asked a Bard/Gleeman (musician) to one of the ones to come after her. ponder.gif

Posted by: Shard Jun 16 2009, 07:09 AM

Many theorize that Mat will lose an eye, give up have his sight = light.

The game of Foxes and Snakes is how to win against the Finns since they ARE the Foxes and Snakes. They must cheat, bring fire, iron, music and courage. Notice how Rand used that Fire sword against them effectively.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 17 2009, 09:15 AM

But Rand won't be coming with them. Something I picked up on this time when Rand is viewing the Aiel history is that they used to work with the Ogier (the Nim?) to help make things grow. Now they only sing when they go into battle.

Music again!

Posted by: Shard Jun 17 2009, 09:45 AM

That is true Rand and no channeler will be going with them. However there are other ways to get fire, and it seems they need Iron so that shouldn't be hard for them to get.

Posted by: Owain Jun 17 2009, 11:16 AM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Jun 17 2009, 09:15 AM) *
But Rand won't be coming with them. Something I picked up on this time when Rand is viewing the Aiel history is that they used to work with the Ogier (the Nim?) to help make things grow. Now they only sing when they go into battle.

Music again!


I think the Nim were the Green Man's race and something different and rarer than Ogier?

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 17 2009, 12:28 PM

Welcome to the discussion, Owain! I was wondered about that as I was listening to that part. And the Green Man who died at the end of EotW was the last of his race, wasn't he? But the Aiel were part of that. Is that the song the Tu'atha'an(sp?)(traveling people) are looking for?

Shard, I keep hearing references to music that I've never noticed before. That group of 10,000(?) Aiel who formed a circle around the psycho male Aes Sedai and tried to sing him out of the destruction he did--and he killed them all, but then offed himself at the end. Man, those were really bad times. No wonder everyone is so scared of men who can channel!

And what was the giant orb the men and women Aes Sedai blew up trying to use the One Source (as opposed to the true source) --the one both male and female can use? The power that Moridin is now using? That's seriously dangerous stuff.

It is rather funny, though, that Mat asked to have the holes in his memory filled and failed to mention that he meant to have his own memories back. Oh, well, as long as it helps win the battle with the DO. Since he's dealt with both groups of Finns, I hope he's better prepared and doesn't lose his temper this time and do something stupid.

Something about Rand's journey through Aiel history made me wonder. Was the DO already bound? Has he been bound before, escaped, and was bound again by Lews Therin and his 100?

And Brandon answers a question on his http://www.brandonsanderson.com/blog/796/Reader-Mailabout the DO:

QUOTE
Don writes:

"I wanted to comment on the general impression that nothing BIG changes with each turning of the Wheel, i.e., history repeats itself. It's mentioned in the books and has been confirmed by RJ in interviews. I take issue with this, however. The DO can influence the world AND he is outside the Pattern and the turning of the Wheel. History doesn't repeat for the DO. In his quest to break the Wheel, why would he repeat the same steps over and over again, knowing they don't work? He remembers and learns with each turning of the Wheel. Because of this, I feel that the possibility exists that something "different" could happen, and that perhaps this something "different" might happen at the end of this series. No one really agrees with me, though. : ("

I wanted to answer this one, since there has been a lot of talk about Warbreaker on the blog lately, and I wanted to do something for the Wheel of Time readers. Don, you're actually quite right. The Dark One CAN stop the Wheel from turning. Indeed, this is his goal. So far, history has repeated for the Dark One--but only because he has failed at his attempts to unravel the Pattern.

Now, the theory websites can go into all of this in much more depth (and specificity) than I can. I'm no replacement for Robert Jordan when it comes to continuity and cannon within the Wheel of Time world. (Except where it comes to the last volume.) Many questions and thoughts like this are better sent toward Bob at the Encyclopedia WoT or on the forums at Theoryland or Dragonmount (or on any of the other excellent websites.) However, this particular topic was one I decided I needed to delve into during my research for the final books. If I didn't understand the Dark One's motivations and goals, I didn't think I could do the Last Battle justice. And so, I can state with reasonable authority that the Dark One is indeed capable of doing what you say. Though, it should be noted that in many cases, the Dark One's actions will repeat themselves--he will try the same ploys, though I can't speak for certain on how much he has varied those over the years.. But I can promise that just because he has failed in the past doesn't mean he will fail again.

This series could end with the Dark One breaking the Wheel and destroying the Pattern. That is what is at stake.

Posted by: Shard Jun 17 2009, 10:16 PM

Somestra, aka the Green Man, is the last of the Race of Nym. The Nym were magic constructs to help with growing crops, probably part of the reason world hunger was wiped out.

Now I don't know if the songs the Nym used are the same as the Ogier but if they are the Tinkers have already listened to and rejected the Growing Song as the song they are seeking.

Some theorize that there is no song, that the Tinkers built up this legend of the Song to cure everything.

I thought it was sad reading about that part where the mad AS was fixated on the singing Aiel. They did it to keep him occupied so the people of the city could escape.

The sphere I think was the Sharom, it was a research center for Science and experiments with the One Power.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 18 2009, 09:28 AM

But it's not the same as Saidar and Saidin, correct?

Posted by: Shard Jun 18 2009, 11:21 AM

No it is not, it's the DO's power is what Moridin and other Forsaken are using.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 18 2009, 11:23 AM

Holy Cow! What were those male and female Aes Sedai thinking of then in trying to use it? You'd think if they knew it was the DO's power source they wouldn't want to have anything to do with it. Could that have turned some of them?

ETA: *gasp* I never noticed before that Lord Luc (Rand's uncle) killed Rand's Aiel father!! ohmy.gif

Another ETA: Back to that thingy that blew up when they tried to use a new source of the One Power. From the http://www.encyclopaedia-wot.org/:

QUOTE
* Mierin and Beidomon tap into what they think is a new source of the One Power and unexpectedly open a hole into the Dark One's prison. The Sharom at the Collam Daan explodes in black fire. (TSR,Ch26)

* Mierin proclaims her allegiance to the Great Lord of the Dark in the Hall of the Servants. (TDR,Ch36)


Now Mierin is who Lanfear was fighting on side of the Light before she turned to the shadow. But it appears she didn't turn to the shadow until after this experience with the Sharom. Does trying to use that power source taint the user? Were there others who became the Forsaken part of that group?

Or did Lanfear turn to the dark because Lews Therin spurned her? Pretty lame excuse, imho, but if you're walking a fence anyway it wouldn't take much to cross over one way or the other. ponder.gif

Posted by: Shard Jun 19 2009, 08:19 AM

Yes Slayer is responsible for many deaths, I wonder if Rand will ever find out about his father's death at Slayer's hands.

According to RJ Lanfear was ready for the Shadow long before the Bore was made. Though being spurned by Lews is probably the excuse she trots out, she really just wants power. Remember Lanfear proposed to Rand that they could take on even the Creator and DO with the Chodan Kal at there hands.

It's power and control which is why some are seduced by his power, like Moridin. There may be some that were forced to the Shadow we just don't know yet.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 23 2009, 12:33 PM

Faile perhaps wants glory more than power, but she still troubles me. But I think I'd like her if she didn't punish Perrin for things he has no way of knowing. She appreciates forthrightness but won't act that way herself.

Verin makes a comment to Perrin just before the big battle at the Two Rivers. She questions whether or not Perrin understands what it means to have married Faile. Perrin obviously does not. Is there any hint of the significance except that Faile appears to be 2nd from the throne, only behind her father?

From http://www.brandonsanderson.com/blog/799/Garden-Ninja-Contest:

QUOTE
If you're following along at home, The Gathering Storm is now in the proofread stage. I got an email letting me know that the manuscript will be coming back after the proofreads in July, and we'll need to have it back by the end of July. Then it's on to production officially. Things are getting close now.

Posted by: Shard Jun 25 2009, 10:17 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Jun 23 2009, 01:33 PM) *
Faile perhaps wants glory more than power, but she still troubles me. But I think I'd like her if she didn't punish Perrin for things he has no way of knowing. She appreciates forthrightness but won't act that way herself.


And thus my entire problem with Faile is laid out succintly and to the point.

QUOTE
Verin makes a comment to Perrin just before the big battle at the Two Rivers. She questions whether or not Perrin understands what it means to have married Faile. Perrin obviously does not. Is there any hint of the significance except that Faile appears to be 2nd from the throne, only behind her father?


I think that's exactly what Verin means but then Verin seems to know alot she doesn't tell anyone so there may be more Wolf King prophcies then we know of. We do know the Broken Crown has been shown around Perrin in Min's visions.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 26 2009, 11:57 AM

Okay, here's something I found curious. Slayer (aka Lord Luc & Isam) can physically move himself from one location to another in Tel'aran'rhiod, right? Well, Perrin's been completely in Tel'aran'rhiod, too. Do you think it could ever be something he could learn to do, or is that just a power of the DO? What Slayer does is almost a kind of traveling.

Also, since he was able to do that, I wonder why Lord Luc after he was hurt by Perrin in Tel'aran'rhiod didn't just transport himself somewhere else rather than running through the Inn. Or was that just a plot ploy to connect the two for the reader? ponder.gif

Posted by: Shard Jun 27 2009, 07:24 PM

So far what Slayer does seems pretty unique but then it is possible Dreamwalkers could do that if they choose to but feel it is an Evil thing to do. Rather a self destructive thing that leads to evil. Being in the Flesh is what Slayer does, I don't know if this is a gift of the DO or if it was something Luc and/or Isam could do anyways.

What seems odd to me is that Gitara had a Foretelling to send Luc to the Blight and I wonder about that. I mean that seems a bad thing that happened there, conversaly sending Tigraine to the Waste was what got us Rand. Seems Foretellings are neutral.

I think there may be more to what and how Slayer Dreamwalks, it could be that only one of the Persona's can do this. That one may have been the injuried one so couldn't get back into TAR and have to leave the premise physically IRW.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jun 27 2009, 07:36 PM

Interesting.

You know that foretelling reminded me that Perrin has seen things in the wolf dream that haven't happened yet. Does his little "furry problem" give him foretelling as well? The instance that I'm particularly thinking of is when he hurts slayer in dream, Perrin sees Mat with that spear being used the bind his arms behind him. That doesn't happen until the next book.

And isn't the http://brandonsanderson.com/blog/786/The-Gathering-Storm-Cover-Art book cover odd? That scene if from the end of KoD--and is Min red/blond? I didn't think so. So who's the red/blond chick on the cover? Isn't Elayne a reddish blond?

Posted by: Shard Jun 28 2009, 11:08 AM

Yes Perrin has Wolf Dreams that allow him to see things. He has yet to tell anyone about them. http://steelypips.org/wotfaq/4_prophecy/4.6_perrin-drm.html can be found there. It seems he hasn't had any for some time now.

Yes the cover is odd and so far no one knows who the Barmaid is supposed to be. Min has short brown hair, Elyane does have reddish blonde hair but I doubt she'd dress like that. Some think it's supposed to be Avi, when we saw the rough draft she was more appropriatly dressed for an Aiel Wise Woman. Now she looks like some wetlander barmaid so really looks OOC for her. Though that's really not new with Darryl Sweets art covers for wot. *sigh* Why couldn't we have a Marie Gran Pre for the covers I don't know.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jul 7 2009, 06:40 PM

Too right about Marie Gran Pre. Warbreaker's cover is beautiful to look at. Too bad Tor doesn't pay up for a better artists for the WoT books.

In Fires of Heaven, I'm at the part where Rand has saved Cairhien from the Shaido and Mat has killed Couladen. Mat just cracks me up! I'm enjoying him more and more every time I read this series.

Unfortunately, the catty girl crap is starting in earnest. I just wish those sections didn't have information so pertinent to the storylines. *sigh* I'm a girl. Why do I like the guys' storylines so much better?

But here's a question. What role do you all think Valan Luca is going to play? He must have a destiny in the final battle, because he keeps showing up.

Brandon gave us a little heads up on http://www.brandonsanderson.com/blog/803/DONE today:

QUOTE
(Also, WoT readers, I haven't forgotten you and am not ignoring you. WoT13 is going very well, and I'm excited about the progress. We're on target for a November next year release, at the latest. I wish I could give you details about the books, but I'm under some pretty tight restrictions about what I can say. Once TGS is out in November, I think I'll be more free to talk about what's in the next book.)



ETA: How did Moghedien hide the fact that she could channel when she was masquerading as the mother with two boys? That would be a pretty handy ability if you were hiding yourself from the Seanchan.

Posted by: Shard Jul 8 2009, 12:15 PM

Well with the Valan Luca question I think he HAS served his purpose as a "vehicle" first for Nynaeve and then later Mat. I really don't see him having a part in the final battle.

Moggy later on shows the Wondergirls how to disguise the ability to channel.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jul 8 2009, 10:12 PM

Is it the whole inverted weave thingy? That's what first came to mind, but that hides when you're channeling. I was thinking about the ability to see someone else who could touch the source but isn't. Is it the same thing?

Posted by: Shard Jul 9 2009, 11:45 AM

I believe there is a weave or something that can disguise the ability to channel. In KoD Suian uses spirit to make a weave to hide her ability to channel.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jul 24 2009, 11:12 AM

I must have just forgotten it then. Funny how on subsequent read through we pick up things that we just blew past previously. That's something that's nice about this series. There's so much there, that it's fun to read them again.

After listening to the first five books, I've been taking a break and listening to some other books. I'm about ready to begin again with Lord of Chaos. I keep coming back to the title of Book 6, since it's part of the closing comment in KoD made by Taim to those poor Red Ajah emissaries.

ETA: Was Taim a dark friend from the beginning? If he was 15 years older than Rand, how did he keep from going nuts from the taint? And why didn't he try to declare himself the Dragon Reborn sooner?

Posted by: Shard Jul 26 2009, 11:36 PM

We don't know yet, also the Taint does affect each male differently in some it takes longer then others.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jul 27 2009, 09:24 AM

But 15 years? That's WAY longer than anyone Rand has heard of. It just makes me wonder if he has the same protection that the male Forsaken have--a link to the DO. But Rand was able to see that link, wasn't he? Could a link like that be hidden by an inverted weave, I wonder? ponder.gif

Unless, Taim wasn't born with it but was taught--perhaps by a forsaken. Hmmmm . . . I don't know.

Posted by: Shard Jul 28 2009, 02:40 PM

I think the connects aren't always showing, I think they only show under certain circumstances. Either they only show in TAR, meaning that Rand was battling the various Forskan in the Flesh in TAR not just Rahvin. Perhaps when he's holding enough power himself, or maybe something else we don't know about.

As for Taim that's a good theory actually maybe he was taught by a Forsaken, handpicked to be a False dragon from the begining. It's certainly plausible.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jul 28 2009, 11:19 PM

Okay, I'm at the part where Mat meets Olver for the first time. Something occurred to me. We've basically been assuming that when we've seen Gaidal in Tel'aran'rhiod in the earlier books that he hadn't been born again yet. Is that a safe assumption? What if his presence there was because when he dreams he can still go there--even as a child (Olver)?

Just can't waste that ugly face. It has to mean something.

Also, where do you all think the plot point is for Alanna bonding Rand against his will? I know she helped to find him when the Aes Sedai kidnaped him, but Perrin was there, so she was really unnecessary? I wonder what more could happen with that bond.

Also, assuming that Moiraine surives the rescue, I wonder if she will be changed--perhaps be more powerful and/or have critical information Rand will need? ponder.gif

Posted by: Shard Jul 29 2009, 09:34 AM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Jul 29 2009, 12:19 AM) *
Okay, I'm at the part where Mat meets Olver for the first time. Something occurred to me. We've basically been assuming that when we've seen Gaidal in Tel'aran'rhiod in the earlier books that he hadn't been born again yet. Is that a safe assumption? What if his presence there was because when he dreams he can still go there--even as a child (Olver)?


RJ said no that Cain is not Olver.

QUOTE
Just can't waste that ugly face. It has to mean something.


Not always

QUOTE
Also, where do you all think the plot point is for Alanna bonding Rand against his will? I know she helped to find him when the Aes Sedai kidnaped him, but Perrin was there, so she was really unnecessary? I wonder what more could happen with that bond.


Remember when Rand gets kidnapped? That's the reason for the bond.

QUOTE
Also, assuming that Moiraine surives the rescue, I wonder if she will be changed--perhaps be more powerful and/or have critical information Rand will need? ponder.gif


She will be changed I am sure and I don't know if it will be info she has more just the fact that. "Hey it's ok to let us women die in battle, it's OUR choice bloody ashes get it you woolheaded fool already!"

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jul 29 2009, 07:30 PM

QUOTE(Shard @ Jul 29 2009, 08:34 AM) *
QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Jul 29 2009, 12:19 AM) *
Also, where do you all think the plot point is for Alanna bonding Rand against his will? I know she helped to find him when the Aes Sedai kidnaped him, but Perrin was there, so she was really unnecessary? I wonder what more could happen with that bond.


Remember when Rand gets kidnapped? That's the reason for the bond.

So do you think that will be the only role she will serve?

Posted by: Shard Jul 31 2009, 08:33 AM

Pretty much yeah, it's sad too because she was the first Green I think we meet and so I was very interested in knowing her character more. Then she went and basically raped Rand. Now Rand is bonded to three others so there isn't much need for Alanna.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Jul 31 2009, 10:05 PM

I got to that part in the book, and it made me wonder about the nature of multiple bonds. Since the girls bonded Rand, how did that work for Min? Elayne bonded Birgitte, but Elayne was also the one who could channel. Did Rand bond Min or did Elayne or Avienda do the bonding for her. That's interesting--an Aes Sedai can perform bonding between people who could not otherwise be bonded?

I can't remember who the girls were feeling when Rand and Elayne had their little "wild thing" encounter. Were they experiencing Rand's feelings or were they also picking up on Elayne's. If they were picking up Elayne's that implies that Greens who have more than one warder can pick up what the other warders are feeling. That would be pretty intrusive if that's the case.

Posted by: Shard Aug 1 2009, 07:32 AM

Min's bond is like that of a Warder, or Brigitte's though I don't remember clearly if the girls could sense each other or not. I know that they can now all sense Rand and feel his feelings.

Well the Wise Ones did a bonding between Elayne and Avi, they have stated they can do this for anyone. So long as they pass their test of course, then they are Spiritually linked.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 1 2009, 03:12 PM

I reread what I wrote and I didn't say it well. If the girls were picking up Elayne's feelings (while they were bonded to Rand) that implies that two warders bonded to the same Aes Sedai would be able to pick up what each is feeling. Does that make sense? The warders would be able to feel each other. If that's the case, it's a pretty intrusive thing, being bonded--more so than I ever thought.

So is Elayne going to be impacted with Birgitte's romance when/if she finally finds Gaidal Cain?

Eeewww

Posted by: Shard Aug 2 2009, 03:54 AM

Well I do know that the Aes Sedai can muffle things on their end. Non-channler Warders don't seem to have as much luck. Then again maybe Brigitte, Avi and Min weren't used to the sort of training Warders go through.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 7 2009, 03:06 PM

I've gotten to the point in LoC where Egwene travels to Salidar via Tel'aran'rhiod. I'd completely forgotten that she got there that way. She seemed to come through without any problems, so I wonder where the Wise Ones concerns originated. Something bad must have happened. But it also makes me think that Egwene could leave the White Tower any dang time she wants--via Tel'aran'rhiod.

I love how in KoD she's slowly getting everyone to her side via respect.

And that whole ceremony where Egwene is made Amyrlin and everyone present has to prove they are women by baring their breasts--they already have a fox in the hen house and don't even know it: Halima Saranov aka Aran'gar formerly known as Balthamel before Rand killed him.

This is all so hard to keep track of. My head hurts! headdesk.gif

Posted by: Shard Aug 9 2009, 04:00 PM

As for going into TAR via the Flesh I think it's a build up thing. The more you do it the more you damage yourself. Egwene has only done it once and so may have only minimal and maybe healable damage. Where as Rand has probably done this more then just when he fought Rahvin.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 13 2009, 09:09 AM

Woot! Looks like The Gathering Storm is coming out a week earlier than expected!

From http://www.brandonsanderson.com/blog/815/The-Gathering-Storm-coming-sooner-than-expected:

QUOTE
This afternoon I got word from Tor that the release date of THE GATHERING STORM has officially been moved up one week. The new on-sale date in the U.S. and Canada will be October 27, 2009, so mark your calendars. We don't yet know if other markets will be following suit; as more information comes in I'll keep you posted.

Posted by: Inveli Aug 14 2009, 01:48 PM

For those who don't know yet, the first part of A Memory of Light has been reviewed. Supposedly, this reviewer got the permission of the author to get this copy and he says that the book is just as good as The Great Hunt, The Shadow Rising, and The Fires of Heaven.



QUOTE
Before you read my review, I need to give you full disclosure. It’s important to remember my point of view. I’m running a large fan site for a book series that is very near and dear to my heart. Over the years I came to know Robert Jordan, and am proud to have had him call me friend. I am close to Harriet, his widow, as well as to other members of his family and staff. I consider Brandon Sanderson to be my friend (as long as he lets me win a few MAGIC: The Gathering games anyway). I am affiliated with http://www.tor.com/ (Robert Jordan’s U.S. publisher) via personal relationships, small business deals, and as of recently, their website, http://www.tor.com/, for which http://www.tor.com/index.php?blogger=Jason_Denzel. That said, I have not ever accepted money or other payment from them to promote, endorse, or write nice things about their Wheel of Time products.

So, with all that in mind, I tell you truthfully: My review below is for you, the reader who wants the truth, and not the hype. I am not here to sell you the book. I am here to tell you, as one fan to another, what you can expect from this new installment in the WoT series. While the facts of my disclosure above will never make me completely neutral, I promise you that my primary responsibility and obligation remains, as always, to give it to you straight. Like you, I am a fan first and foremost.


The best, and least spoilery, summary of the review is this:

http://www.amazon.com/Gathering-Storm-Wheel-Time/dp/0765302306/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1249054771&sr=8-1
QUOTE
http://www.amazon.com/Gathering-Storm-Wheel-Time/dp/0765302306/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1249054771&sr=8-1 is, in my opinion, quite easily one of the most intense and exciting books in the entire Wheel of Time series. Yes, you read that right. I avoided writing this review right after I finished reading. Instead, I purposely waited some time to let the initial rush and enjoyment wear off. It certainly has cooled a great deal, but I can still say with grounded and sober confidence that the book is outstanding. I would rank it up there in the top 4 in the series along with The Shadow Rising, The Fires of Heaven, and The Great Hunt. Pacing-wise, I would agree with Brandon Sanderson’s statement that it’s similar to books 4-6 in the series.





For the whole article, you can go http://www.dragonmount.com/News/?p=585. Beware! There are some potential spoilers, so be careful. If you want the book to be fresh to you when it comes out, then I say, don't read the review.





Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 15 2009, 12:02 PM

Awesome! Thanks so much for the links and comments.

Here's some of what I was interested from http://www.dragonmount.com/News/?p=585 by Jason Denzel at dragonmount.com:

QUOTE
So now the other burning question: does this feel like a Robert Jordan novel? Does it have his “voice”? Well, truthfully, I thought the prose stayed very true to previous novels. But ultimately you’re going to be the judge on that. Brandon Sanderson has gone on record several times saying that he is not trying to mimic Robert Jordan’s voice. That doing so would just be parody. What he set out to do, and what I think he accomplished, was to tap into that font of story and events in the universe that previously had been experienced and documented by Robert Jordan. Rather than trying to make himself and his style like RJ, it seems like Brandon put himself into the heart of the saga and allowed himself to be its vessel and storyteller. The result is that this book is clearly and undeniably a novel which belongs in the WoT series. There were only a few times where I suspected the scene I was reading was entirely from Brandon’s imagination. We may never learn which specific sequences he had to invent entirely, but in the end, you probably won’t notice or even care. It’s pretty seamless in that regard. If you have read Brandon’s other novels, you’ll probably pick out pieces of text that phrase things in a way that “sound” more like his writing. Some character names sound like they might be from the Mistborn world rather than Randland. And some characters, for me, were not exactly as I pictured them. The strange thing about that though, was that another person closely tied to the project said that they thought a certain character “was off” and I thought that character was perfectly represented. On the other hand, characters I felt were different seemed spot on to that person. So no matter what I say about it, you are going to bring your own experience and vision of each character with you, and whether or not you agree with their interpretation in Gathering Storm is up in the air.

The most obvious fact in all of this is that Brandon put his heart into this book. Even though it’s a thick tome, none of it feels padded or rushed. Before he was the writer tasked with finishing this series, he was a fan like you and me. He clearly knows what fans like and dislike, and has crafted a novel that primarily follows in the footsteps of its predecessor while also delivering in a way that he knows will go over well with the crowds. (And to be fair, a lot of that insight was probably shared by Robert Jordan as well. Knife of Dreams was a great book that had a lot of steam behind it.)

I am saddened by the thought that this part of the series will inevitably play out differently than if Robert Jordan were still with us. It’s a loss that fans will always feel and wonder about; maybe it could loosely be described as a “wound that cannot heal.” I suspect that Brandon himself feels that more keenly than most. However, after literally just a few chapters, I was reassured. Guided by a strong plot outline, familiar characters, and a knowledge of the franchise that was honed to a razor sharp edge by lots of research, it became quickly apparent to me (or “intuitively obvious to the most casual observer”) that Brandon was the best person in the world to take this gig, and that he did as fine as a job as was even possible. For that, I am his biggest fan…. until November 3rd at least, at which point you will be.

In the end though, I suspect that all thought of voice and different styles will fade away as you follow that familiar opening wind in chapter one. You’ll reunite with these characters we’ve been following and once again become completely immersed in the struggles and adventures of this great saga. There’s no doubt that The Gathering Storm deserves an equal place on your top shelf next to the previous eleven volumes. Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson have crafted a remarkable novel fraught with dark, foreboding themes that will remind you why you first fell in love with the series to begin with. Even though we know it’s Brandon who pulled the actual words together, this is undeniably Robert Jordan’s work, and perhaps one of his best.

This is very encouraging to me. It's a tough thing to take up something written by someone else and continue the story. When they tried to do a sequel to Gone with the Wind, it was dreadful--a travesty. I was encouraged when I began reading Sanderson's other works to see how I liked his writing style. I love it! He's one of my favorite authors now. Can't wait to see more of his works. But I've been worried about how he handle finishing this series.

Dang! I can't wait!! *sigh* But I'll have to . . .

Posted by: Inveli Aug 15 2009, 06:43 PM

I know how you feel man(or are you a women?). But the book is just around the corner, so the least we could do is be patient. Anyway, time to stimulate some discussion. Ever wondered what "giving up half the light of the world, to save the world" is? Well, I think(I think though) I got the answer right here. This was a prediction made by somebody else and I wish to spread the theory. Look down here:

QUOTE
Mat will lose an eye, either in the Last Battle or in the Tower of Ghenji. I believe this as Egwene Dreams him putting his eye on the scale, and the prediction that he will "give up half the light of the world" in order to save it. I take this to mean that he will lose his eye in order to save the world. I also believe that Mat bears some stark similarities to the Norse god Odin:
-Odin was known as the "Father of Battles" whilst Mat as the "son of battles.
-Both are known gamblers
-Both wear wide brimmed hats and carry spears
-Mat's spear has two ravens on it, Odin had two ravens Huggin and Munnin who each day told him the news of the Earth
-Huggin and Munnin means "thought and memory" in norse wythology, Mat's raven-marked spear is inscribed with "Thought is the arrow of time, memory never fades.
-Both Odin and Mat were hanged upon "Tree's of Life", Odin upon Yggdrasil and Mat Avendesora in order to achieve knowledge
-Odin only had one eye as he sacrificed his eye to gain knowledge of the all time and see how to win Ragnarok (norse final battle and end of the world) and I believe that Mat will do something similar.
I believe that the similarities between Mat and Odin exist, although I could be wrong. But this prediction seems to hold true to the prophesies and my percieved ideas of the similarities between Mat and Odin.
Please post any opinions.



Now discuss.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 15 2009, 06:59 PM

Works for me, Inveli--and it makes sense. I found that to be very curious when I read it. Perhaps it happens when Mat, Thom, and Farstrider go after Moiraine. That review of the book certainly hints that that event takes place in this new book. I hope so, because I would love to see Moiraine be able to come back for the last battle. We've certainly seen enough

I have a question about warder bonds (hmmm, seems I remember an actor by that name lol.gif ). I've been listening to CoS (not Chamber of Secrets) and when Rand would only allow Alana to heal him it made me think about other bonds. Warders seem to have a compelling need to protect their Aes Sedai. Is that part of being a warder and warder training and indoctrination or is it part of the bond. If it's that latter, what does that say for those Aes Sedai who were bonded by Ashaman? Will they have a compelling need to protect the men? ponder.gif But Rand doesn't have a compelling need to protect Alana, but has she been in a situation where she was in need of his protection?

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Aug 15 2009, 08:33 PM

I'm not going to go and have a look at that whole review, but the bits that have been posted here are very interesting, and as Seven of Nine says, encouraging. I am very keen to read this book, and I do hope that the date for it comes forward here as well as in the US and Canada. This is the second most impatient I've been for a book lol.gif

Posted by: Inveli Aug 16 2009, 09:11 AM

Yes, I always wondered what Matrim would look like with an eye-patch on. It seems pretty cool to me, the concept. So, I suppose that means that Mat is going to lose an eye to learn how to win Tarmon Gaidon and get Moiraine back, which is also beneficial to the war efforts because Min said so herself that without Moiraine, Rand al'Thor is nothing...or something like that. But yeah, Mat's awesomeness never ceases to amaze me. Also, I have a prediction of my own.

Legitimate Prediction Down Here

Egwene has dreamed about Mat a couple times, right? And usually in those dreams, there are fireworks in them, right? Well, I've noticed that sometimes, the dreams show "powerful arrows of fire" coming out of it, right? And the book usually forshadows an Illuminator that is looking for Mat(likewise, Mat was also looking for an Illuminator at one point). Well, I predict that Mat will have firearms during Tarmon Gai'don aka "Shock Lances"(as they are called in the Age of Legends). What do you think? It makes perfect sense.

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 15 2009, 07:59 PM) *
Works for me, Inveli--and it makes sense. I found that to be very curious when I read it. Perhaps it happens when Mat, Thom, and Farstrider go after Moiraine. That review of the book certainly hints that that event takes place in this new book. I hope so, because I would love to see Moiraine be able to come back for the last battle. We've certainly seen enough

I have a question about warder bonds (hmmm, seems I remember an actor by that name lol.gif ). I've been listening to CoS (not Chamber of Secrets) and when Rand would only allow Alana to heal him it made me think about other bonds. Warders seem to have a compelling need to protect their Aes Sedai. Is that part of being a warder and warder training and indoctrination or is it part of the bond. If it's that latter, what does that say for those Aes Sedai who were bonded by Ashaman? Will they have a compelling need to protect the men? ponder.gif But Rand doesn't have a compelling need to protect Alana, but has she been in a situation where she was in need of his protection?


I think for Warders-in-training, it's both training, morals, and the bond. But for Aes Sedai, I don't think they'll be as protective or lenient to the guys they were bonded to. Though I suppose it is possible. Definitely possible.

Also, there is a theory that has been going around lately and I think you guys should see this. Remember, this is from somebody else, not mine. Look:

QUOTE
Ok, this is my first theory.

I think that Rand will win the Last Battle and survive, though he will be badly injured. He will get better/be healed, then go as a beggar to Tar Valon where he will be brought to the Tower and gentled by Egwene. He will probably die soon after.

First, Rand will win the Last Battle and survive.

There are 6 references to Rand’s blood in the Karaethon Cycle.

“Like the unfettered dawn shall he blind us, and burn us, yet shall the Dragon Reborn confront the Shadow at the Last Battle, and his blood shall give us the Light.â€

"Twice dawns the day when his blood is shed.

Once for mourning, once for birth.

Red on black, the Dragon's blood stains the rock of Shayol Ghul.

In the Pit of Doom shall his blood free men from the Shadow."

"The blood of the Dragon Reborn on the rocks of Shayol Ghul will free mankind from the Shadow."

"His blood on the rocks of Shayol Ghul, washing away the Shadow, sacrifice for man's salvation."

-Min’s viewing, TEotW chapter 15

“Black rock wet with bloodâ€

There are seven references to Rand’s death.

-Twice in the Dark Prophecy, TGH chapter 7,

“Her new lover she seeks, who shall serve her and die, yet serve still.â€

“Two roads before him, one to death beyond dying, one to life eternal.â€

-Nicola’s Foretelling, LoC, chapter 14,

“Three on the boat and he who is dead yet lives.â€

-In The Karaethon Cycle, TGH chapter 26

“Twice and twice shall he be marked,

twice to live and twice to die.â€

-Min’s viewing, TEotW chapter 15

“Three women standing over a funeral bier with you on itâ€

One of the answers to Rand’s questions to the Aelfinn,

“If you would live, you must die."

-Egwene's dream

"A man lay dying in a narrow bed, and it was important that he not die, yet outside a funeral pyre was being built, and voices raised songs of joy and sadness."

CoS, Chapter 10, Unseen Eyes, Page 203

Why would people be singing for joy at a funeral, unless it was the Dragon Reborn’s funeral?

So, yes, Rand will die, but not necessarily at Tarmon Gai’don.

Cadsuane thinks that Rand might survive Tarmon Gai’don.

"He is turning into a stone, Verin, and if he doesn't relearn that he is human, winning the Last Battle may not be much better then losing.†WH, chapter 25

“He must learn that even the Dragon Reborn is flesh. If he goes to Tarmon Gai’don as he is, even his victory may be as dark as his defeat†Cadsuane to Sorilea, PoD, chapter

How could winning Tarmon Gai’don be nearly as dark as losing unless the Dragon Reborn was alive to make it so?



Second, he will go to Tar Valon as a begger and then go, or be brought against his will, which I think is more likely, to the Tower.

-Perrin’s dream.

“ Perrin thought it was Rand. He wore rags and a rough cloak, and a bandage covered his eyes.â€

-Egwene’s dream TSR,Ch11

“Rand in chains, and it was he who was screaming.â€

-Moridin’s sha’rah game

“The Fisher was always worked as a man, a bandage blinding his eyes and one hand pressed to his side, a few drops of blood dripping through his fingers. The reasons, like the source of the name, were lost in the mist of time. That troubled him sometimes, enraged him, what knowledge might be lost in the turnings of the Wheel, knowledge he needed, knowledge he had a right to. A right!

Slowly he set the Fisher back on the board. Slowly his fingers uncurled from around the cour'souvra. There was no need for destruction. Yet. Icy calm replaced rage in the blink of an eye. Blood and wine dripped from his gashed hand, unnoticed. Perhaps the Fisher did come from some remnant of a memory of Rand al'Thor, the shadow of a shadow. It did not matter. He realized he was laughing, and made no effort to stop. On the board, the Fisher stood waiting, but in the greater game, al'Thor moved already to his wishes. And soon, now. . . .It was very hard to lose a game when you played both sides of the board. Moridin laughed so hard that tears rolled down his face, but he was not aware of them.â€

PoD, Prologue.

Rand has something wrong with his eyes, and a wound in his side that’s always breaking open, so it’s safe to assume that Rand is the Fisher.

At the Tower, Egwene will be the Amyrlin and she will gentle him.

During Rand’s trip by Portal Stone, in one of his lives,

“Egwene, stern-faced in the stole of the Amyrlin Seat, lead the Aes Sedai who gentled him.†TGH, chapter 37

“A dozen Aes Sedai surrounded three men, two of them burly guards with the Flame of Tar Valon on their chests, tugging the chains in which the third stumbled as if dazed. Egwene jerked forward in her chair. The chained man was Rand. Eyes half-closed, head sagging, he seemed to be nearly asleep, moving only as the chains directed.

“This man,†Elaida proclaimed, “has named himself the Dragon Reborn. This man has channeled the One Power. There is only one penalty for this, known and recognized in every nation, but pronounced only here in Tar Valon, in the Hall of the Tower. I call upon the Amyrlin Seat to pronounce the sentence of gentling on this man.†TDR, during the third arch of Egwene’s test for the Accepted. Now, we know that Ter’angreal is somehow related to the Ter’angreal that allows the wearer to enter Tel’aran’rhiod. I think that it is quite possible that Egwene’s test for the Accepted, or at least the third part of it was somehow connected to reality instead of what it was for every other Novice who was tested. During the third Arch, she saw herself as the Amyrlin, with Beldiene as her Keeper. Beldiene is a young Dragonsworn Green. She saw Elaida as her main enemy in the Hall of the Tower, and she remembered something called “The Great Purge†where all the Black Ajah in the Tower were revealed, which is something that Seaine, Pevera Doesine, Saerin and Yukiri are working on right now.

Rand will most likely be gentled as a punishment for killing like, five, Aes Sedai, stilling three, and making the rest swear fealty to him, and who knows what else.

So, I think that at Tarmon Gai’don Rand will reseal the Bore with a circle of 72 Aes Sedai and Ash’aman, he will either be badly injured, [probably by the wound in his side breaking open] or else he will actually die and come back to life. Either way he will spill his blood all over Shayol Ghul and the Pit of Doom. He will be rescued by Elayne, Avaindha & Min, go to Tar Valon, and then be brought to the Tower and gentled by Egwene.


You can find this http://www.theoryland.com/theories.php?func=5&rec=127&theo=2582


Discuss.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 16 2009, 01:45 PM

As you can tell by my signature, I'm thinking that Rand is going to die but he's going to live. Not sure how this would be accomplished, but I think dying is the only way to be free of Lews Therin, and it fits in with Min's viewing of three women around a funeral pyre.

I don't think Rand will be gentled, because he's cleaned the source. There's no point. If he's gentled, what point would be served except to take a weapon from a crazy man. Better that he just die outright.

Posted by: Inveli Aug 17 2009, 12:51 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 16 2009, 02:45 PM) *
As you can tell by my signature, I'm thinking that Rand is going to die but he's going to live. Not sure how this would be accomplished, but I think dying is the only way to be free of Lews Therin, and it fits in with Min's viewing of three women around a funeral pyre.

I don't think Rand will be gentled, because he's cleaned the source. There's no point. If he's gentled, what point would be served except to take a weapon from a crazy man. Better that he just die outright.


For what ever reason, it could happen. Min saw a Begger's Staff over Rand's head, so he's definitely going to be involved. Remember, even when the source is cleansed, think about it. Rand stilled three Aes Sedai and did all kinds of things to him. Now, Rand had his reasons and even Aes Sedai deserved to be punished, but Aes Sedai don't see it that way. They don't and even Egwene is more Aes Sedai than before.

Plus, there are tons of ways he could survive and the architypes the characters follow and the hints the story gives may very well see to Rand surviving Tarmon Gai'don. For example, as the story unfolded, I simply noticed a few parallels between it and an ancient doctrine called Gnosticism, which may give a clue as to how the story will keep unfolding. Gnosticism was about the myth of the Dying God, (whom in the most popular version is called Jesus) who was born of a virgin, was accompanied by 3 Mary's, died to save the world and was resurrected. This myth was echoed throughout the ancient world (the real world) and some modern books and movies have attempted to echo it also; e.g. the matrix, where there is a saviour called Neo, who in the first movie dies only to be resurrected, and just happens to have a lover named 'Trinity' paralleling the 3 Mary's, or the pagan 'triple goddess'. Similarly, Robert Jordan seems to be thinking along Gnostic lines; Rand is a saviour born of a maiden, has 3 lovers, and the Prophecy of the Dragon says his blood will be on the rocks of Shayol Ghul- he is going to die to save the world, as per the ancient myth of the Dying God, and then, possibly, he will be somehow resurrected.

Or perhaps, "his blood on the rocks" may refer to Slayer (the Luc half, anyway). The whole story has said time and time again that prophecies aren't always what you would expect them to be. They could mean totally different things. Noal Charrin might even reveal to Rand that he is Jain Farsrider, and advise him on how to fake his death, thus avoiding that begger fate. But clues seem to point to the begger that Rand could become. We'll just have to see.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 18 2009, 08:43 PM

I think the worst thing for Rand is having Lews Therin in his head. It has had its advantages by giving Rand knowledge of things he shouldn't have known about. But it's never a good thing to be talking to yourself--especially when the other voice is a raving lunatic who wants to kill everyone.

I'm trying to figure out what's going on with him though and his use of the power--it started when Moridin took his hand and helped him in Shadar Logath. It's been suggested that all the voices Rand hears aren't necessarily from Kinslayer.

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Aug 19 2009, 01:05 AM

QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 18 2009, 05:51 AM) *
Or perhaps, "his blood on the rocks" may refer to Slayer (the Luc half, anyway). The whole story has said time and time again that prophecies aren't always what you would expect them to be. They could mean totally different things. Noal Charrin might even reveal to Rand that he is Jain Farsrider, and advise him on how to fake his death, thus avoiding that begger fate. But clues seem to point to the begger that Rand could become. We'll just have to see.

I've always felt there had to be something more to that particular phrase. Rand is far too certain that it will be him, his blood, his death for me to be secure. I like the idea that it could be his blood, as in his relation. That would be a nice twist on the words.

I sure hope Rand doesn't die, or that if he does that he lives again because he has been through far too much for this to be his end. I also hope that he isn't gentled. I remember people saying they thought Harry would have to give up magic to 'win' and I couldn't handle the thought that after being through so much that he could lose it all. And I don't want that for Rand either. The way they describe gentled people surviving is horrific. Besides, it can be healed now, so why bother in the first place.

Posted by: MTBlond Aug 19 2009, 04:02 AM

I'm sure someone has already mentioned this, but I couldn't find it anywhere...:

What do you think Lan's reaction will be when he realizes his brother is still alive (in a way, at least) and similarly, how will Rand react when he finds out that his uncle - Tigrane's brother - lives too. And then, when they find out that they are now two sides of the same person.

Posted by: Inveli Aug 19 2009, 11:04 AM

QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Aug 19 2009, 02:05 AM) *
QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 18 2009, 05:51 AM) *
Or perhaps, "his blood on the rocks" may refer to Slayer (the Luc half, anyway). The whole story has said time and time again that prophecies aren't always what you would expect them to be. They could mean totally different things. Noal Charrin might even reveal to Rand that he is Jain Farsrider, and advise him on how to fake his death, thus avoiding that begger fate. But clues seem to point to the begger that Rand could become. We'll just have to see.

I've always felt there had to be something more to that particular phrase. Rand is far too certain that it will be him, his blood, his death for me to be secure. I like the idea that it could be his blood, as in his relation. That would be a nice twist on the words.

I sure hope Rand doesn't die, or that if he does that he lives again because he has been through far too much for this to be his end. I also hope that he isn't gentled. I remember people saying they thought Harry would have to give up magic to 'win' and I couldn't handle the thought that after being through so much that he could lose it all. And I don't want that for Rand either. The way they describe gentled people surviving is horrific. Besides, it can be healed now, so why bother in the first place.


About Rand: Even if he is gentled, tortured, and executed, Rand is too much like Jesus and Thor. As a matter of fact, regarding Thor, Rand's last name pretty much proves that. Rand al'THOR, right? In fact, Thor is a norse god, but al'Thor means "son of Thor". Plus, don't forget. He could either fake his death like Jain Farstrider(Noal Charrin) and he could be resurrected like Jesus. Rand's stark similarities bewteen Jesus is amazing, to say the least.

It's like Matrim Cauthon. He possesses an archetype based off of the Norse god Odin. As a matter of fact, he is very much like Odin. For example, refer to this:

QUOTE
Mat will lose an eye, either in the Last Battle or in the Tower of Ghenji. I believe this as Egwene Dreams him putting his eye on the scale, and the prediction that he will "give up half the light of the world" in order to save it. I take this to mean that he will lose his eye in order to save the world. I also believe that Mat bears some stark similarities to the Norse god Odin:
-Odin was known as the "Father of Battles" whilst Mat as the "son of battles.
-Both are known gamblers
-Both wear wide brimmed hats and carry spears
-Mat's spear has two ravens on it, Odin had two ravens Huggin and Munnin who each day told him the news of the Earth
-Huggin and Munnin means "thought and memory" in norse wythology, Mat's raven-marked spear is inscribed with "Thought is the arrow of time, memory never fades.
-Both Odin and Mat were hanged upon "Tree's of Life", Odin upon Yggdrasil and Mat Avendesora in order to achieve knowledge
-Odin only had one eye as he sacrificed his eye to gain knowledge of the all time and see how to win Ragnarok (norse final battle and end of the world) and I believe that Mat will do something similar.
I believe that the similarities between Mat and Odin exist, although I could be wrong. But this prediction seems to hold true to the prophesies and my percieved ideas of the similarities between Mat and Odin.
Please post any opinions.



So yeah, I think Rand's gonna live. And if he is resurrected, he'll be good as new(One Power, no insanity, etc.).


Regarding Matrim Cauthon: I think I said before that Mat will probably have firearms during Tarmon Gai'don aka "Shock-lances", as they were called in the Age of Legends. In Chapter 15, Aludra is even looking for a bellfounder, right? Well, let's not forget that a bellfounder can be used for a cannon, eh? So, in other words, Aludra will rediscover "shock-lances" and cannons or what ever they were called during the Age of Legends. Think about it. Mat...with a pistol. Egwene even dreamed of Mat having "shock-lances". So, what do you guys think?


Regarding Olver: Well, let's put it straight, Olver is NOT Gaidal Cain, or whatever is name is. But I have a feeling that Olver will be for Birgitte. This is what Min saw:

QUOTE
Auras danced around her and images flickered, more than Min had ever seen around anyone, thousands it seemed, cascading over one another. Those multitudes of images and auras flashed by too quickly for her to make out any clearly, but she was certain they indicated more adventures than a woman could have in one lifetime. Strangely, some were connected to an ugly man who was older than she, and others to an ugly man who was much younger, yet somehow Min knew they were the same man.


So my theory is that Olver will sneak into the Tower of Genji and the Eelfinn will make him loses a couple years of his life for something he wants which would thus, mature him into a man. dry.gif So yeah, that's what I think.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 19 2009, 01:34 PM

QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Aug 19 2009, 12:05 AM) *
QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 18 2009, 05:51 AM) *
Or perhaps, "his blood on the rocks" may refer to Slayer (the Luc half, anyway). The whole story has said time and time again that prophecies aren't always what you would expect them to be. They could mean totally different things. Noal Charrin might even reveal to Rand that he is Jain Farsrider, and advise him on how to fake his death, thus avoiding that begger fate. But clues seem to point to the begger that Rand could become. We'll just have to see.

I've always felt there had to be something more to that particular phrase. Rand is far too certain that it will be him, his blood, his death for me to be secure. I like the idea that it could be his blood, as in his relation. That would be a nice twist on the words.

Same here Harry's Horntail. Besides, you can spill blood and not die. I just think Jordan had something in mind that would not necessarily require Rand's existence to end. I don't want him to die either.

And I don't know that he'd had to live in a grand palace and be rich and powerful to be happy. When I think of the three women he loves, I keep going back to Min as the one best suited to him. She likes to call him Sheepherder, and he could certainly make a life by being one with her by his side. Some people would suggest that that would be a step back and make him a beggar. The people at the Two Rivers would disagree.

QUOTE(MTBlond @ Aug 19 2009, 03:02 AM) *
What do you think Lan's reaction will be when he realizes his brother is still alive (in a way, at least) and similarly, how will Rand react when he finds out that his uncle - Tigrane's brother - lives too. And then, when they find out that they are now two sides of the same person.

Lan's brother? Do you mean Isam Mandragoran, aka Slayer? Luc is also one facet of Slayer. See http://www.encyclopaedia-wot.org/, Characters. He killed Rand's Aiel father.

As for brothers, I'm interested in the meeting of Rand and his half brother Galad (and also Elayne's half brother).

Posted by: MTBlond Aug 19 2009, 01:56 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 19 2009, 12:34 PM) *
QUOTE(MTBlond @ Aug 19 2009, 03:02 AM) *
What do you think Lan's reaction will be when he realizes his brother is still alive (in a way, at least) and similarly, how will Rand react when he finds out that his uncle - Tigrane's brother - lives too. And then, when they find out that they are now two sides of the same person.

Lan's brother? Do you mean Isam Mandragoran, aka Slayer? Luc is also one facet of Slayer.



Yes, I mean Isam - it's been a while since I've read the books (since 11 came out) - I was mistaken about his relation to Lan. Regardless, I am aware that he is one part of the man called Slayer, as is Luc (who is Rand's uncle). My question is, how do you think Lan and Rand will react to knowing that their familiy members are alive (in a manner of speaking) and that they are, or have been, working for the Dark One.

Posted by: Inveli Aug 19 2009, 05:40 PM

QUOTE(MTBlond @ Aug 19 2009, 02:56 PM) *
QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 19 2009, 12:34 PM) *
QUOTE(MTBlond @ Aug 19 2009, 03:02 AM) *
What do you think Lan's reaction will be when he realizes his brother is still alive (in a way, at least) and similarly, how will Rand react when he finds out that his uncle - Tigrane's brother - lives too. And then, when they find out that they are now two sides of the same person.

Lan's brother? Do you mean Isam Mandragoran, aka Slayer? Luc is also one facet of Slayer.



Yes, I mean Isam - it's been a while since I've read the books (since 11 came out) - I was mistaken about his relation to Lan. Regardless, I am aware that he is one part of the man called Slayer, as is Luc (who is Rand's uncle). My question is, how do you think Lan and Rand will react to knowing that their familiy members are alive (in a manner of speaking) and that they are, or have been, working for the Dark One.


I wouldn't contemplate that just yet, Harry's Horntail. For me, why guess something when we don't even know? Yeah, I know people try to puzzle things out and make theories on certain matters based on the story, but why should we guess on how they'll react? It could be answered in the next book. Or the one after that. Or the last one, for that matter. I'd at least wait till The Gathering Storm comes out. Well, if you must, I just think they are both going to be angry...I guess. Honestly, I don't think it should be considered a mystery, just simple curiosity.


Anywho, anyone have any ideas on Logain's Glory(the thing Min saw in him)? Many people are still trying to puzzle it out.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 19 2009, 05:51 PM

QUOTE(MTBlond @ Aug 19 2009, 12:56 PM) *
QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 19 2009, 12:34 PM) *
QUOTE(MTBlond @ Aug 19 2009, 03:02 AM) *
What do you think Lan's reaction will be when he realizes his brother is still alive (in a way, at least) and similarly, how will Rand react when he finds out that his uncle - Tigrane's brother - lives too. And then, when they find out that they are now two sides of the same person.

Lan's brother? Do you mean Isam Mandragoran, aka Slayer? Luc is also one facet of Slayer.

Yes, I mean Isam - it's been a while since I've read the books (since 11 came out) - I was mistaken about his relation to Lan. Regardless, I am aware that he is one part of the man called Slayer, as is Luc (who is Rand's uncle). My question is, how do you think Lan and Rand will react to knowing that their familiy members are alive (in a manner of speaking) and that they are, or have been, working for the Dark One.

Honestly? At this point in the story? I'm wondering if Rand can even be shocked anymore. The poor guy's had to deal with so much in such a short period of time I really feel for him. And as he tries to become stronger by becoming harder . . . ugh!

QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 19 2009, 04:40 PM) *
...For me, why guess something when we don't even know? ....

Anywho, anyone have any ideas on Logain's Glory(the thing Min saw in him)? Many people are still trying to puzzle it out.

Hmmm. why guess something we don't even know? wink.gif

I'm hoping it has to do with the last battle and helping Rand. I like Logain, and I wish Rand felt he could trust him.



Posted by: Harrys Horntail Aug 19 2009, 06:04 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 20 2009, 10:51 AM) *
Honestly? At this point in the story? I'm wondering if Rand can even be shocked anymore. The poor guy's had to deal with so much in such a short period of time I really feel for him. And as he tries to become stronger by becoming harder . . . ugh!

I'm reading the early books again, and I miss the naive, sweet Rand from those days so much. I still love later book Rand and I feel so sorry for him, but I far preferred the old Rand. I hope he finds his way back before the end. You're right, he just seems to be so hardened to everything the world throws at him at the moment.

QUOTE
I'm hoping it has to do with the last battle and helping Rand. I like Logain, and I wish Rand felt he could trust him.

I like Logain too, and I think Rand will come to it in time. After all, it seems to be Logain's faction versus Taim's and I know which of those two I would trust. I'm hoping his glory has something to do with him helping Rand and the others at the end, too.

Posted by: Inveli Aug 20 2009, 11:23 AM

QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Aug 19 2009, 07:04 PM) *
QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 20 2009, 10:51 AM) *
Honestly? At this point in the story? I'm wondering if Rand can even be shocked anymore. The poor guy's had to deal with so much in such a short period of time I really feel for him. And as he tries to become stronger by becoming harder . . . ugh!

I'm reading the early books again, and I miss the naive, sweet Rand from those days so much. I still love later book Rand and I feel so sorry for him, but I far preferred the old Rand. I hope he finds his way back before the end. You're right, he just seems to be so hardened to everything the world throws at him at the moment.

QUOTE
I'm hoping it has to do with the last battle and helping Rand. I like Logain, and I wish Rand felt he could trust him.

I like Logain too, and I think Rand will come to it in time. After all, it seems to be Logain's faction versus Taim's and I know which of those two I would trust. I'm hoping his glory has something to do with him helping Rand and the others at the end, too.


Hmmm, lots of people say that Logain is gonna be the new Tamrylin. What do you guys think?


And while you guys are thinking about that, I'm going to ask you this: Have you read Ask The Forsaken on the dragonmount.com? It's really hilarious. I think you guys should check it out http://www.dragonmount.com/OurCommunity/?cat=6

QUOTE
Dear Sammael (Sam, Sammiekins?),

I have a big sporting tournament coming up in June and I was wondering if you had any suggestions as to how I could train for it? The incredibly daft competition organisers have outlawed interesting things like using steroids and using the power to incapacitate the opposition so I must use more mundane means to win. As the sporting legend of your Age (and indeed all Ages) I expect that you are the best equipped of all the Chosen to answer my question.

Moghedian
PS: Semi, I-I-I-I-I-I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU-U-U-U-U-U-U!!!!

Dear Adoring Fan (The Mogniator, Mog…),
I can feel the excitement in your question to me. But you really did not need to scent your letter with perfume as it comes off as needy… and stalkerish. Not that I don’t mind a stalker here or there, as I have many. I think you are deep down asking yourself have you can be as awesome as me. I don’t know if we can succeed in such little time in getting your body as well sculpted as mine so you are just going to have to wing it. I would suggest, you know, actually getting out of your house and going to the gym. I find this is a great first step in training for any competition.

Yours Truly,

Sammael

Moghedian,
Firstly, I’m not sure if I appreciate you picking a name so close to mine. I’m going to consider it a tribute of sorts, and not call in that favors Semirhage and Graendal owe me (or will owe me once they realize I have those pictures of them still waiting to be published!) to get you to change your mind.

Secondly, don’t listen to Tiny McKnob here – I’m pretty sure he’s been weaving Illusions at us all this time, and that his family got rich on selling those ‘Mr. Muscle’ gag suits.

-Moghedien

Moghedian,
First of all…why do you presume to have a name so close to one of the other Chosen? I mean, you are asking for trouble doing that, and you could at least have picked a better Chosen to emulate. Moggy never DOES anything, just sits around and waits for things to happen. What do you do to copy her? Sit at home watching Jerry Springer with a gallon of ice cream? That is no way to win a sporting tournament. You gotta get on a diet, girl! Eat healthy and get a lot of exercise. I could give you some tips on where I get MY exercise, but I don’t think that it would be appropriate for family programming.

~Aran’gar Balthamel

I would not recommend going to Sammael for training advice, as he was, and probably still is quite happy to get help by what he refers to as “vitamins”. Something that should be blatantly obvious if you look at his inability to keep his temper in chack, and even more obvious if you have ever been in the sauna with him…Not everything grows if you use those “vitamins”, you know.
/Dem

Dear Moggy-wanna-be,
Sam is a legend? Really? Who’d you have to sleep with to get that title lumped on you, Sammie-poo?

Frankly, my advice would be to get more creative with how you use “the power to incapacitate the opposition.” They can’t prosecute what they can’t prove.

~Messy

Dear Mog2
Seriously? Sammael?? Girl, you wouldn’t get so excited if you’d seen him from my perspective. Granted, that’s from about 1 foot higher Tongue

Your best course of action is to immediately start sleeping during the day, then spend your nights jogging around to your competitors’ houses, tying photos of Agi around bricks and throwing them through their bedroom windows. This will disturb their sleep, fry their minds once they see the photos, and you will get fit doing it. Always combine exercise with pleasure! Or pain. Preferably both.

Lots of … some kind of warm fuzzy feeling
Semi
ps: photos enclosed at no extra charge.

Dear Moghedian,
I do not understand this need of yours for sweat and bad hygiene. The best way to feel a winner is not participate in the tournament at all and feel pretty. It might not win the actual competition, but at least you’d smell like a winner Which is, ultimately, the important thing.

Graendal

Graendal- Beautiful and stupid is no way to go through life. Somebody smarter should have culled you out of the gene pool a long time ago.
Semi- Yes, yes, you’re tall. Sammael is short. We get it. What I want to know is if those pictures are the famous “Two Aginors, One Cup” photos. If so, you are crueler than I imagined, and I warn Mog2 to keep your eyes averted while tying them to the bricks. Otherwise you will need more mind bleach than was ever made.

Moggy (the real one, not the poseur)- Nothing could be worse than the Agi pictures. Unless it is Graendal and Semi IN the Agi pictures.

XOXO– Balthamel


QUOTE
Hi Evil Forsaken!

Do you guys cry yourself to sleep when you think about how much better Sammael is than the rest of you? I also heard that Ishamael still wets his bed… is this somehow related to him being better looking than you too?

Keep up the Evil!

-Leammas

‘Dear’ Leammas,
Why would I cry myself to sleep for not being a short, slashed-up egomaniacal loser? I mean, I’ve never been one to care too much about fashions or trends (unless there was some way to exploit a quick bit of gold out of it), but I somehow doubt that the vogue thing this year is egomaniacal losers. And anyways, we already know from someone or another having a Foretelling that he’s going to die a horrible, lonely loser death, so perhaps we should be pitying the poor idiotic fool.

-Moghedien

Leammas,
I appreciate my fan’s questions unlike the other Chosen who get a bit jealous. It is a burden to be so popular with the common folk.

Yes, I heard Ishy has nightmares and has some problems in that area. I am sure you are on to something about him being jealous of me though. Good catch.

Keep being awesome true believer.

–Sammael

Only tears I would ever shed over Sammael is because such an intellectualy challenged midget is allowed to share the glory that comes by being given the title Chosen.
Dem

Dear Lemur Leammus,
I don’t cry over men, at all. So I’m going to have to say no there. If Sammy boy could find a good plastic surgeon and grow an inch or two, perhaps something could be done, though. I don’t think crying would be the appropriate term. That’s more Semi’s area.

As for Ishy, I’m more likely to believe someone’s trying to put out the flames in his head than him wetting himself. Do you know, while we were sealed up in that big hole, that he actually lit Moggy’s skirts on fire? I don’t think I’ve ever seen her that mad. Of course, maybe that’s his version of flirting? I wouldn’t put it past her to be the one trying to snuff him out, though.

~Messy

Dearest Lemming,
Know that you have now made it onto the very short list of people whose souls are earmarked for a very special form of treatment, and that you will literally be steamed, well, ‘alive’ for lack of a better way to put it, over and over in a Sysiphean task to make even the Marquis deSade wince in horror. Know that it is not water, nor lemon juice nor even a fine chianti I have saved for you, but three thousand years of fermented chamber pots.
To answer your question though, there is nothing to envy in the carved up meat sack that makes up Sammael, know that every time you gaze into a blazing fire, or even the twinkling of a match the beauty of my form stares back at you, patient, waiting, and ready to raze destruction at the slightest misstep.

Mesaana, I wouldn’t reccomend bringing that up here, Moghedien still hasn’t cooled off from that last bit of bickering, and the balm Semirhage hasn’t helped much either.

-Ishamael

When will people learn that signing their name backwards stopped working after the second time somebody tried it? Seriously, who would have such lousy self-esteem that they need to send a letter praising themselves to make themselves feel better?
Although it must be stated that Ishy does have nightmares about fire extinguishers.

-Asmo

Praytell, Asmodean, how do you know that Ishamael actually dreams about fire extinguishers? If anything, it sounds like another one of your drug-addled fantasies. And if you’re fantasizing about fire extinguishers, I think I actually feel more sorry for you than I thought was possible.
-Moghedien

Dear Leammas *coughSammaelcough*,
I am perfectly confident in my abilities to sleep well at night. Unlike Ishy, I need no “plastic sheets” of this Age to avoid soiling my bed.

The pure egotism of you Sammael never ceases to to amaze me. When there is nobody else to stroke his ego for him, he must stroke it himself.

*looks around and giggles*

Perhaps I have said too much.

~~Aran’gar Balthamel

Plastic Sheets, Balthamel? Do you know what happens when I try that? They melt, then they burn. Do you know how hard it is to sleep with the smell of burning plastic? This is why I only sleep on the bed of vestal sacrifices… This way I smell barbeque all night long. This also has the added bonus of making me the envy of all the male Chosen except Asmodean.
~Ishamael, Master of the Grill.

Leammas dearest,
You have to be more specific. Names mean nothing to me. A description would make it easier for me to answer that. And no, “the ugly one” won’t focus my attention span either. But, if you swing something shiny in front of me, it should. Anything under 24 carets would be frowned upon, though. You’ve been warned!
Also just so you know, I don’t cry. Ever. My own little effort in helping to conserve our water resources. Every little bit helps

Graendal

Ishy still cries himself to sleep because I won’t go on a date with him? How … sad *smiles serenely*
Dear Lemming

You – me – white room with metal table and bright light – tonight?

Semi

Ishy: Nobody is jealous of your barbecue bed. Roasting meat or not, it still smells like urine, no matter what claims you make about your “special marinade”.
Graendal– Look, a shiny! *weaves an explosive ward into a heavy golden collar and tosses it across the room* Go get it, Grennie! It will make you even more beautiful when you put it on. Seeing her without a head would definitely be beautiful… Really, go try it out!

Semi– I think I express the thoughts of us all when I say: “Ew.”

Ligatures and Lollypops,
Balthamel


QUOTE
Dear Asmodean,

Now that Valentine’s Day is coming up and all, I couldn’t help wondering how you spent it? I’m especially curious about how Lanfear felt about having to spend Valentine’s without her pookie. Considering all kinds of fun he could have had with all of his other girlfriends…
And Sammael, I’ve heard that you are a real ladies man (I’ll pretend I didn’t hear about that “Old Tongue” episode). Any tips for the rest of us not as lucky with the fairer sex?

-Mareina

______________________________________

‘Dear’ Mareina,

Just what makes you think that the word ‘dear’ can be safely applied to us? Prudence, Lightfool. Anyway, now that Valentine’s has passed, and we’ve disposed of the bodies, I’ll deign to respond to your petty query. I personally spent Valentine’s Day in front of a piano, playing many of the classics of this Age and my own. That evening, I went to a martini lounge, listened to a live band play some light jazz, and returned to my lair. I do not see the point of spending Valentine’s Day getting ‘hot and sweaty’ with a mortal whose lifespan is insignificant in comparison to mine. Instead of wasting the emotion on them, why not put it into something that will last: my music?

As for Lanfear, she spent Valentine’s Day in bed with the blankets pulled up over her head, sobbing rather loudly over her pictures of Lews Therin, or ‘Lewsie-Poo’, as she calls him.

And for the Sammael comment… *balefires Mareina* That’s for bringing that bloody awful image to mind!

-Asmodean

______________________________________

Mareina,

What an excellent question, especially the part when you pointed out how the women swoon when they are near me. Let’s see if we can get you a date.

1. You gotta be confident. I mean ooze confidence. Ladies love a man with a big ego.

2. Good pick up lines. It is all about the first impression. If you are opening well, you will ‘close’ if you get my drift. Personally I reference my scar which is always a great ice breaker.

3. Being famous. I can’t help you there, because you are a lowly mortal that has zero chance of being as awesome as me. You best bet is to know someone famous. So telling the ladies you wrote into the Ask the Chosen column and that I responded to you will not hurt. I mean, they may start going on and on about me, but if they are thinking about how good looking I am that may distract from the way you look.

4. Lastly, talk about yourself in the third person. Tel Janin has never met a woman that did not respond to that.

–Sammael

______________________________________

I spent Valentine’s Day turning people red and sending them to my fellow (lesser) Chosen. Wrapping them up in ice took care of the white part (and incidentally prevented the blood from messing all over the place). If you want, you can be one of my presents next year. Who would you like to be sent to?

- Semi

______________________________________

And Tel Janin is also a fan of platform shoes. It brings him to the level of any female companions he may be attempting to seduce. He had a hard time for awhile; all he ever did was stare at women’s breasts. Granted, it’s not his fault that they were at eye-level.

-Asmo

______________________________________

WHY is it that Sammael has the ladies’ man rep, despite all of the obvious evidence to the contrary?

As for myself, I spent part of Valentine’s Day with Lews Therin, not because he is particularly attractive in this Age, but because I like to see Lanfear squirm. And after that, I had a very good time with your mother. (Or was it your father….?) *shrugs*

~~Balty’gar

______________________________________
Yes, you do get around, don’t you? And why you seem to think styling yourself after an Indian curry is clever is beyond me. But then, I think you must have lost some wits when you found your ----…

As for myself? Valentine’s Day is just another day. Granted, the fools are distracted either moping about their poor wretched fates, or too busy blowing all their money trying to get a bit of loving, so I took advantage of it. I had minions selling beer, flowers, and chocolates. Of course, I’m sure that none of them appreciated the special ingredient really. Not that I’m going to tell you what that was – you’ll just have to follow them into the bathroom to find out!

-Moghedien

______________________________________

Valentine’s Day is a strange thing this Age has concocted to make people feel bad for a) not having someone to spend it with or b) totally screwing up the presents. Have you ever stopped to think about what the holiday actually is?

A man feels responsible for taking his significant other out for dinner (or stay in for dinner, whatever). He gets dressed up, combs his hair for the first time all week, actually takes a bath, and washes his car. Then he appears at her doorstep, offers her flowers and/or chocolate (let’s not even discuss what these two things actually ARE…) and takes her to eat somewhere that he really can’t afford. And to make matters worse, by the time they get home, whether dinner was good or not, the woman feels responsible for reciprocating amorous feelings in the form of a kiss (and since this isn’t the Howard Stern show, I’ll stop there).

Then, they blame the whole thing on cheap wine and a little kid running around in a diaper and shooting people with a bow and arrow.

There really has to be a better way to celebrate love than by faking it. Seriously.

~Messy
PS- I spent mine with a few Warders I borrowed from the Greens. Do you think they’ll notice?

______________________________________

Considering that your idea of foreplay is to strap them to a wall and channel at their brains, I’m willing to bet even the retarded children they’ve bonded noticed the oddity in their head. That is, of course, unless they were too deep in their cups romancing their other Warders. But that is neither here nor there – flowers, anyone? Guaranteed to surprise your choice of date this year!

-Moghedien

______________________________________

I spent the day dressing up a couple of trollocs as warders. Incidently, as warders belonging to a couple of Greens…

Oh, Messy? You might want to let Semi examine your girly parts. Just saying…

/Dem

______________________________________

You sure you don’t rather want me to examine YOUR girly parts, Dem-dem? *smiles … Semi style*

Semi

______________________________________

I would laugh, but that might give you the impression that I find either of you entertaining.

However, props to the Torture Queen! I think his girly parts are definitely at issue and he’s in denial. Perhaps Arangar has someone he can talk to about these issues now?

~Messy

______________________________________

I don’t need a shrinker of heads for my problems, I simply pick out a few people who annoy me and shrink their heads for them when I need to blow off some steam. It is not disconcerting at all to be a virile man living in a beautiful woman’s body. I have the best of both worlds. A gorgeous figure to look at in the mirror, and my keen male intelligence is untroubled by “PMS”. I think THAT is the reason none of my female counterparts have ever managed to succeed in their bids for the Great Lord’s favor– He KNOWS you can’t trust anything that bleeds for 5 days and doesn’t die.

~Balty’gar



QUOTE
If Demandred sent an army of Trollocs from, lets say Caemlyn to sack Tar Valon, and at the exact same time, let say, Rahvin, sent another army of Trollocs, but this time from like, Fal Dara to sack Tar Valon, which army would get there first? Which army would succeed? Who would get credit?

~~MV

_________________________________________________

Demandred’s army would get there first, of course. Rahvin would be too busy playing with the prettiest trollocs to pay attention to what direction they were heading in.

- Semi

_________________________________________________

None of the armies will get there. They’ll meet up, no doubt, and play tea party all day. Until they get tired of using plastic tea cups and start using tinkers instead.

Graendal

_________________________________________________

Wasn’t this question on the Age of Legends version of the SAT?

–Sammael

_________________________________________________

Congratulations, MV, for posting the dumbest question in the history of ATC.

Rahvin’s only concern in life is Compelling all the pretties he can find, and making them adore him. Not that anything actually happens once said Compelling has been made, the self-proclaimed Casanova-wannabee may talk a lot about his conquests, but in reality, he would not know where to start. Being alone with women intimidates him.

That said, Rahvin would be so focused on Compelling whatever skirt he can get his hands on, so if he even remembered to send an army out, they would most likely end up somewhere in the Aiel Waste. The guy is about as smart as Semirhage is compassionate and caring. I mean, last time he tried to beat me to something like this, he used a gateway to send his trollocs…

/Dem

_________________________________________________

I have much better things to do with my time than answer a question like this. If you must know, it would be futile for either one of them to try, as I will be Nae’blis once I have schemed my beautiful self to the top.

~~Balty’gar

_________________________________________________

Balthamel, you never cease to amuse me. Except, of course, when you become boring. In this case the idea of you as Nae’blis is down right humorous. I really appreciate being the one to break it to you, but you can’t sleep your way to the top of this food chain.

MV,
Although I’m astounded at the banality of your line of questioning, you have a better sense of realism than Balthamel, and for that I congratulate you. Even if it isn’t saying all that much.

Ultimately, who gets to Tar Valon first is irrelevant. Namely because I’ve been their and done that. As your Julius Caesar so eloquently put it, Veni Vidi Vici. No other power in history has been able to recreate the feats I accomplished in the Trolloc Wars, and no other power will match my own feats until I decide to recreate them. When such a day comes all you hold dear will burn before my gaze and you will assuredly be punished by having to answer an endless stream of inane questions such as this. This punishment will ensue until you claw your eyes out and then you will have the questions read to you.

~Ishamael “Heart of the Dark” Ba’alzamon

_________________________________________________

I claim the credit by virtue of being the most intelligent of the Chosen. Class dismissed.

-Asmodean

_________________________________________________

Most intelligent, Asmodean? Really? I always thought you were deranged for choosing immortality so you could compose music of all things (there are MUCH better ways to spend eternity), but this really shows that you have gone off the deep end.

~~ Aran’gar Balthamel

_________________________________________________

Asmodean, how in the Great Lord’s name can you make such a false claim? The last time I saw you, you were giggling at your toes. I’m thinking that whatever drugs you’ve been on lately, they’ve taken you to a special little world all your own. And trust me – I don’t want to be there.

-Moghedien

_________________________________________________

I think I just blew Coca-Cola through my nose. It burns. That truly was funny, Asmo, and I’m not just saying that. You should call those Blue Collar guys and see if they can get you set up with a gig or two. Who knows? They might even think you’re funny with instruments to torture them with.

I’ll say Dem gets his army there first, but Rahvin gets his to actually do something besides shopping. By “do something” I actually mean stopping for dinner at this neat little tavern about a block inside the West Gate. They roast White Cloaks every Thursday there and it’s really a rousing good time.

Neither army would succeed, because these are trollocs we’re talking about. All you have to do is toss a turkey leg the opposite direction and they’ll run after it just like rabid dogs. Or Asmo if you toss his flute.

And anyone who accepts the blame for this debacle will totally deserve what they get. Personally, I will be the one on the gate tossing turkey legs. Mostly at Asmo, though.

~Messy

_________________________________________________

Mmmm…turkey legs….

Hmm, where was I? Oh yes… I never said “Sleep” my way to the top Ishy, I said “scheme” my way to the top. I save my ’sleeping’ for people I would enjoy it with (which definitely would not include any of you losers!) One day, when you least expect it…there I will be, placed above you and ready to order you and the other Chosen to do my bidding in the most amusing ways. Mesaana, have you ever considered becoming a contortionist? You will.

~Aran’gar Balthamel

_________________________________________________

You couldn’t scheme your way out of your dress, Balthy *rolls eyes*

- Semi

_________________________________________________

At least I know what I have under my dress and how to use it, Semirhage. I wouldn’t be surprised if a cloud of dust arose when you change your…well, I won’t finish that sentence as it makes me slightly sick to think of it.

~Balty’gar



Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 20 2009, 01:52 PM

QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 20 2009, 10:23 AM) *
Hmmm, lots of people say that Logain is gonna be the new Tamrylin. What do you guys think?

From what I can find out, the Tamyrlin was a ring worn by Lew Therin. Is it supposed to be a title or position in the future?

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Aug 20 2009, 07:48 PM

I know most of us haven't been exactly thrilled with the cover art we've seen so far for the next book, but this guy, Seamas Gallagher, has done some interesting art based on WoT. You can see his stuff http://seamassketches.blogspot.com/search/label/wheel%20of%20time. It obviously doesn't strive for realism but I find it very compelling.

Posted by: Inveli Aug 20 2009, 08:48 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 20 2009, 02:52 PM) *
QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 20 2009, 10:23 AM) *
Hmmm, lots of people say that Logain is gonna be the new Tamrylin. What do you guys think?

From what I can find out, the Tamyrlin was a ring worn by Lew Therin. Is it supposed to be a title or position in the future?


If I'm correct, the Tamrylin is the leader of both male and female One Power-users.

QUOTE(MysteryloverAnne @ Aug 20 2009, 08:48 PM) *
I know most of us haven't been exactly thrilled with the cover art we've seen so far for the next book, but this guy, Seamas Gallagher, has done some interesting art based on WoT. You can see his stuff http://seamassketches.blogspot.com/search/label/wheel%20of%20time. It obviously doesn't strive for realism but I find it very compelling.


Not bad.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 20 2009, 10:36 PM

QUOTE(MysteryloverAnne @ Aug 20 2009, 06:48 PM) *
I know most of us haven't been exactly thrilled with the cover art we've seen so far for the next book, but this guy, Seamas Gallagher, has done some interesting art based on WoT. You can see his stuff http://seamassketches.blogspot.com/search/label/wheel%20of%20time. It obviously doesn't strive for realism but I find it very compelling.

Thanks for sharing that link. I think my favorite is the picture of Thom. I really like him. Since there are hints he'll have a nice big role in the next book, I can't wait for another reason! lol.gif

Since the only way to win snakes and foxes is to cheat, and Moiraine said in her letter that there must be no more than 3 who come after her, does that mean it'd be a good thing for a fourth party (Olver?) to sneak along--even though Moiraine said that having more or less than three would spell disaster? ponder.gif

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Aug 21 2009, 07:22 AM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 20 2009, 10:36 PM) *
Thanks for sharing that link. I think my favorite is the picture of Thom. I really like him. Since there are hints he'll have a nice big role in the next book, I can't wait for another reason! lol.gif


I loved the one of Thom, too! I thought he really captured his personality.


QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 20 2009, 10:36 PM) *
Since the only way to win snakes and foxes is to cheat, and Moiraine said in her letter that there must be no more than 3 who come after her, does that mean it'd be a good thing for a fourth party (Olver?) to sneak along--even though Moiraine said that having more or less than three would spell disaster? ponder.gif


Actually, this part of the story is more intriguing to me than the 'blood on the rocks' - perhaps because it involves two characters who have become my faves over the course of the books, Mat and Thom.

Posted by: Inveli Aug 21 2009, 11:00 AM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 20 2009, 11:36 PM) *
QUOTE(MysteryloverAnne @ Aug 20 2009, 06:48 PM) *
I know most of us haven't been exactly thrilled with the cover art we've seen so far for the next book, but this guy, Seamas Gallagher, has done some interesting art based on WoT. You can see his stuff http://seamassketches.blogspot.com/search/label/wheel%20of%20time. It obviously doesn't strive for realism but I find it very compelling.

Thanks for sharing that link. I think my favorite is the picture of Thom. I really like him. Since there are hints he'll have a nice big role in the next book, I can't wait for another reason! lol.gif

Since the only way to win snakes and foxes is to cheat, and Moiraine said in her letter that there must be no more than 3 who come after her, does that mean it'd be a good thing for a fourth party (Olver?) to sneak along--even though Moiraine said that having more or less than three would spell disaster? ponder.gif


I already discussed that, remember?


QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 19 2009, 12:04 PM) *
QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Aug 19 2009, 02:05 AM) *
QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 18 2009, 05:51 AM) *
Or perhaps, "his blood on the rocks" may refer to Slayer (the Luc half, anyway). The whole story has said time and time again that prophecies aren't always what you would expect them to be. They could mean totally different things. Noal Charrin might even reveal to Rand that he is Jain Farsrider, and advise him on how to fake his death, thus avoiding that begger fate. But clues seem to point to the begger that Rand could become. We'll just have to see.

I've always felt there had to be something more to that particular phrase. Rand is far too certain that it will be him, his blood, his death for me to be secure. I like the idea that it could be his blood, as in his relation. That would be a nice twist on the words.

I sure hope Rand doesn't die, or that if he does that he lives again because he has been through far too much for this to be his end. I also hope that he isn't gentled. I remember people saying they thought Harry would have to give up magic to 'win' and I couldn't handle the thought that after being through so much that he could lose it all. And I don't want that for Rand either. The way they describe gentled people surviving is horrific. Besides, it can be healed now, so why bother in the first place.


About Rand: Even if he is gentled, tortured, and executed, Rand is too much like Jesus and Thor. As a matter of fact, regarding Thor, Rand's last name pretty much proves that. Rand al'THOR, right? In fact, Thor is a norse god, but al'Thor means "son of Thor". Plus, don't forget. He could either fake his death like Jain Farstrider(Noal Charrin) and he could be resurrected like Jesus. Rand's stark similarities bewteen Jesus is amazing, to say the least.

It's like Matrim Cauthon. He possesses an archetype based off of the Norse god Odin. As a matter of fact, he is very much like Odin. For example, refer to this:

QUOTE
Mat will lose an eye, either in the Last Battle or in the Tower of Ghenji. I believe this as Egwene Dreams him putting his eye on the scale, and the prediction that he will "give up half the light of the world" in order to save it. I take this to mean that he will lose his eye in order to save the world. I also believe that Mat bears some stark similarities to the Norse god Odin:
-Odin was known as the "Father of Battles" whilst Mat as the "son of battles.
-Both are known gamblers
-Both wear wide brimmed hats and carry spears
-Mat's spear has two ravens on it, Odin had two ravens Huggin and Munnin who each day told him the news of the Earth
-Huggin and Munnin means "thought and memory" in norse wythology, Mat's raven-marked spear is inscribed with "Thought is the arrow of time, memory never fades.
-Both Odin and Mat were hanged upon "Tree's of Life", Odin upon Yggdrasil and Mat Avendesora in order to achieve knowledge
-Odin only had one eye as he sacrificed his eye to gain knowledge of the all time and see how to win Ragnarok (norse final battle and end of the world) and I believe that Mat will do something similar.
I believe that the similarities between Mat and Odin exist, although I could be wrong. But this prediction seems to hold true to the prophesies and my percieved ideas of the similarities between Mat and Odin.
Please post any opinions.



So yeah, I think Rand's gonna live. And if he is resurrected, he'll be good as new(One Power, no insanity, etc.).


Regarding Matrim Cauthon: I think I said before that Mat will probably have firearms during Tarmon Gai'don aka "Shock-lances", as they were called in the Age of Legends. In Chapter 15, Aludra is even looking for a bellfounder, right? Well, let's not forget that a bellfounder can be used for a cannon, eh? So, in other words, Aludra will rediscover "shock-lances" and cannons or what ever they were called during the Age of Legends. Think about it. Mat...with a pistol. Egwene even dreamed of Mat having "shock-lances". So, what do you guys think?


Regarding Olver: Well, let's put it straight, Olver is NOT Gaidal Cain, or whatever is name is. But I have a feeling that Olver will be for Birgitte. This is what Min saw:

QUOTE
Auras danced around her and images flickered, more than Min had ever seen around anyone, thousands it seemed, cascading over one another. Those multitudes of images and auras flashed by too quickly for her to make out any clearly, but she was certain they indicated more adventures than a woman could have in one lifetime. Strangely, some were connected to an ugly man who was older than she, and others to an ugly man who was much younger, yet somehow Min knew they were the same man.


So my theory is that Olver will sneak into the Tower of Genji and the Eelfinn will make him loses a couple years of his life for something he wants which would thus, mature him into a man. dry.gif So yeah, that's what I think.


Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 21 2009, 11:42 AM

QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 21 2009, 10:00 AM) *
I already discussed that, remember?

Yes--that's why I brought it up again for discussion.

I'd always taken Moiraine at her word--that if more or less than three went, it would mean disaster. I like the idea of Olver sneaking along--it's certainly something he would like to do, I'm sure. But there must be consequences to cheating--even if it is the only way the win.

QUOTE(Inveli @ Aug 20 2009, 07:48 PM) *
If I'm correct, the Tamrylin is the leader of both male and female One Power-users.

According to http://concord.wikia.com/wiki/Ring_of_Tamyrlin, it was a ring worn by Lews Therin.

This is from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hall_of_Servants:
QUOTE
In Robert Jordan's The Wheel of Time fantasy fiction series, the Hall of the Servants was the center of Aes Sedai power in the Age of Legends, analogous to the White Tower in the Third Age. It's unclear if the name referred to the organization of Aes Sedai as well their headquarters (as in Lews Therin Sedai of the Hall of Servants).

The Hall of the Servants was located in Paaran Disen, which was also the center of world government at the end of the Second Age.

The leader of the Servants was known simply as the First Amongst Servants. He or she wore the ring of Tamyrlin as a symbol of their leadership. Tamyrlin was the first person to channel the One Power, and the ring may have been a construct of his or hers, perhaps even the first angreal. Just before the War of Power, Lews Therin Telamon was First Amongst Servants. He was also said to have summoned the Nine Rods of Dominion, which were regional governors of the planet, making him similar in power to a global president. Given the attitude of Aes Sedai and non-channelers in the Third Age it is not likely that all leaders of the Hall of Servants could summon the Nine Rods, but that this power was linked to the individual's ability rather than his or her station as First Amongst Servants.


From http://www.darkfriends.net/wheel/2_nondark/2.4_yore/2.4.06_tamyrlin.html:
QUOTE
Scott Mocklin tells us that the new glossary in To The Blight (vol. 2 of the YA version of TEOTW) has the following entry:
Ring of Tamyrlin (TAHM-ehr-lin): a legendary ring, believed mythical by most people, worn by the leader of the Aes Sedai during the Age of Legends. Stories about the Ring of Tamyrlin include that it was an angreal or sa'angreal or ter'angreal of immense power. It supposedly was named after the first person to learn how to tap into the Source and channel the One Power, and in some tales, was actually made by that man or woman. Despite what many Aes Sedai say, no one knows whether it was a man or a woman who first learned to channel. Some believe that the present title of Amyrlin is a corruption of Tamyrlin.


I hope it's a tool that Rand could use--either himself or someone working with him (Logain being the most likely). If Rand does not end living in a way that places him in a powerful position, perhaps Logain would end up being the leader of the Servants, if they were to start that up again.

I don't see where it's a position though. But perhaps that could be something that is to come. The head of the women is the Amyrlin perhaps the head of the men could be the Tamyrlin after they defeat the DO.

I will be seriously ticked if I've read all these books (over and over again) and the good guys don't win. dry.gif

Posted by: Inveli Aug 21 2009, 06:52 PM

Anyone else think that Egwene can be a hypocritical bitch? Because honestly, she pisses me off at times. As a matter of fact, as a wise man(or was it a women?) once told me, she is one of those "Ooh! Ooh!" girls. dry.gif Making false accusations and sometimes being resentful to the people she should trust. If the "Begger Theory" about Rand is correct, then I predict my annoyance will sky-rocket ten-fold.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 22 2009, 12:26 PM

What particular instance are you referring to where Egwene has been hypocritical? I think she's arrogant--especially for someone as young as she is--and thinks that she knows everything that everyone should do. But then, I think all the characters in this series have tendencies to be arrogant like that and feel they have the right to tell others what they can and cannot do. It's one part of the series that just wears me out.

Egwene's arrogance aside, I believe she's trying very hard to do the right thing. I think what she believes is changing as she grows in knowledge and experience. That's not hypocritical; that's healthy. What really comes to mind is how she's changed her mind about the oath rod vows the Aes Sedai take. She was convinced that they shouldn't use it because it appears to shorten their lives, but Suian has convinced her that their credibility is tied to those oaths.

I can't believe how many times I have read (or listened) to this series and totally passed over the hints about Moiraine coming back. Shard was the one who brought that to my attention, and I'm seeing them all so clearly now that I know to look for them. In CoS I was listening to the part where Min was thinking that the only time her readings on people had failed was relating to "a dead woman" (Moiraine) having to be with Rand at Tarmon Gaidon if there's any chance for them to defeat the DO.

Posted by: Shard Aug 25 2009, 12:30 PM

Lately I've been thinking about both the WT and BT being destroyed to make "Great Arvalon" that was mentioned in those quotes in the begining of one of the books.

I don't know if Logain will head ALL the Channelers but I am sure he will be M'Hael.

Eggy can have some funny logic sometimes but I don't think she's a flat out hipocrite. Elayne is the one that really makes me angry and a little bit Nynaeve as well for their treatment of Mat mostly. Egwene at least believes Mat is a changed man and will be responsible for his own actions where as Nynaeve was all convinced that Mat was this Trolloc in disguise for some bizzare reason in CoS.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 29 2009, 01:50 PM

I have been listening to PoD and I keep thinking of the various people who are committing to Mat and Perrin and the girls--and now those Lan will bring in (maybe Shienar?). I guess they don't all have to know Rand and be committed to him as long as his friends (and through them their followers) are dedicated to Rand. I am sure now that Moiraine is coming back but I was wondering what the major role is she will have to play at the final battle.

Posted by: Shard Aug 30 2009, 07:11 AM

Yes I've always liked that aspect of Team Rand. That if they didn't directly follow Rand they would follow one his "Luitenants" or "Captains". Perrin has Two River Folk with him, Mat and the Band and soon Seachan as well. Galad has the WC, a large portion of the Borderlands will be following Lan. Perhaps Bashere will get the rest, then there's Logain hopefully going to lead the Ashamen.

I think Egwene will be leading the Aes Sedai so no Tamrylin, that was the past and were looking to the future now. I think that's why I don't care for the Sea Folk or Kin they seem kind of inconsequential to the story. Elayne has Andor and Berelain has Mayene, now Darlin is in charge of Tear. I imagine Mattin Stephanos will be getting Illain back and we have yet to see if Elayne really gets Cairherin or not.

I like the attempt of Rand to not repeat Artur Hawkings mistake of leaving his empire a contentious mess after his death. Rand has the foresight of planning what will happen after he is gone. Even in his cold state that he is in now he is still trying to perserve and even create things that will be left behind after he is gone. Like his schools for example, I think he made three though Elayne claimed one rolleyes.gif .

As for Moriane most feel she is going to be the thing that get's Rand over his guilt of letting die or killing women. We don't know what state Moriane is even going to be in when they do find her. It will be really fun to see Mat and Thom with the third person going and get her. We pretty much know they will have to cheat to get her. Though there has always been this vision about Mat having to weigh destiny against two Aes Sedai or two female channlers. I don't feel he has made that choice yet and I think it will involve Moraine somehow, the price of this bet has also been hinted at his eye.

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Aug 30 2009, 01:41 PM

QUOTE(Shard @ Aug 30 2009, 07:11 AM) *
I think that's why I don't care for the Sea Folk or Kin they seem kind of inconsequential to the story.


That is one of the things I liked about Jordan's 'verse - no one group has the entire picture, knows the true history, or has the 'right' philosophy. Some are closer than others, some more powerful, some have abhorrent beliefs (and all have darkfriends among them)....but they will all play a role in bringing about the final showdown. It does make for a confusing cast of characters for the reader and some detours in the plot, but it is so much more interesting reading than other fantasy novels where the one set of peoples have the right (or true) beliefs and all others are wrong or misled. read.gif

Posted by: Seven of Nine Aug 30 2009, 01:46 PM

QUOTE(Shard @ Aug 30 2009, 06:11 AM) *
Yes I've always liked that aspect of Team Rand. That if they didn't directly follow Rand they would follow one his "Luitenants" or "Captains". Perrin has Two River Folk with him, Mat and the Band and soon Seachan as well. Galad has the WC, a large portion of the Borderlands will be following Lan. Perhaps Bashere will get the rest, then there's Logain hopefully going to lead the Ashamen.

Don't forget the people that Faile has inadvertently brought with her through her Shaido captivity. Perrin has a queen as a liege woman, Faile has here little group of very dedicated followers, plus a former queen in the form of Morgaise. They may be loyal to Faile, but she's loyal to Perrin, and he's committed to Rand. lol.gif

About the Shaido--they are headed back to the 3 fold land with a vow never to return. Does that fly in the face of the prophecy that says Rand will unit the Aiel? Or am I remembering it incorrectly?

QUOTE(Shard @ Aug 30 2009, 06:11 AM) *
I think that's why I don't care for the Sea Folk or Kin they seem kind of inconsequential to the story.

I, too, am having a hard time figuring out what their role with be. And that doesn't even count whatever the thing is with that group of people who all suicided for some unknown reason.

QUOTE(Shard @ Aug 30 2009, 06:11 AM) *
As for Moriane most feel she is going to be the thing that get's Rand over his guilt of letting die or killing women. We don't know what state Moriane is even going to be in when they do find her. It will be really fun to see Mat and Thom with the third person going and get her. We pretty much know they will have to cheat to get her. Though there has always been this vision about Mat having to weigh destiny against two Aes Sedai or two female channlers. I don't feel he has made that choice yet and I think it will involve Moraine somehow, the price of this bet has also been hinted at his eye.

Hmmmm . . . could the other woman who can channel (but doesn't chose to) be Tuon?

I must confess that I found this discouraging (it's a quote from http://www.dragonmount.com/News/?p=585)

QUOTE
. . . Robert Jordan described Rand and his situation like this:

The world and the forces of the Light are in bad shape. At this point, boys and girls, the Shadow is winning. There are glimmers of hope, but only glimmers, and they MUST pay off for the Light to win. All the Shadow needs for victory is for matters to keep on as they have been going thus far and one or two of those glimmers to fade or be extinguished. The forces of the Light are on the ropes, and they don’t even know everything the Dark One has up his sleeve.

Think of it this way. The bell is about to ring for the fifteenth round, and the Light is so far behind on points the only way to win is a knockout. Our boy is game, but he’s wobbly on his legs and bleeding from cuts over his eyes. Now he has three minutes to pull out his best stuff and deliver the punch of his life. The Dark One has taken a few shots, but nothing that has really damaged him. He’s still dancing on his toes and talking trash. His head shots can fracture a skull, and his body punches can break ribs. And now he’s ready to unveil his surprises. You didn’t think all it would take is for Rand to show up at the Last Battle, did you? According to the Prophecies, the Light has no chance without him, but his presence doesn’t ensure victory, just that the Light has a chance. Gotta stiffen your legs and blink the blood out of your eyes. Gotta suck it up and find that punch. Three minutes to go, and you gotta find that knockout. That’s your only chance.

I thought we were starting to make progress, but the above quote is really discouraging!


Posted by: Shard Aug 30 2009, 06:20 PM

No the prophecy said that he would break the Aiel and only a remenant of a remenant would survive. This could be the Shaido unless something actually wipes them out anyways.

I've been thinking that when Mat goes to save Moraine there is going to be a Finn trick. What if they present two Morianes but only one of them is legit? Or even something as macabe as Moraine in Lanfear's body. These are just scenarios I've been wondering about with Mat's need to decide between two channlers. Though maybe he has to decide between Toun and Moraine on something else.

Yeah the Light has been good in getting resources unfortunatly their resources are full of wevils and they need to do alot of winnowing.

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Sep 1 2009, 04:30 AM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 31 2009, 06:46 AM) *
I thought we were starting to make progress, but the above quote is really discouraging!

Is it weird that I find it really exciting? That we really are about to come into that final round and it all comes down to how much heart our guys have.

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Sep 1 2009, 07:49 AM

QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Sep 1 2009, 04:30 AM) *
QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 31 2009, 06:46 AM) *
I thought we were starting to make progress, but the above quote is really discouraging!

Is it weird that I find it really exciting? That we really are about to come into that final round and it all comes down to how much heart our guys have.



No - it isn't weird. I had a similar reaction (though the boxing metaphor was a little contrived.) The odds really are against the Light; and winning isn't the same thing as survival - even if the Dark One is defeated, it might be at the cost of lives that are dear to us. As Jo reminded us, people die in wars and orphans are created. A complete victory with happy endings all around would strain our credulity.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Sep 1 2009, 09:49 AM

QUOTE(MysteryloverAnne @ Sep 1 2009, 06:49 AM) *
QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Sep 1 2009, 04:30 AM) *
QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 31 2009, 06:46 AM) *
I thought we were starting to make progress, but the above quote is really discouraging!

Is it weird that I find it really exciting? That we really are about to come into that final round and it all comes down to how much heart our guys have.



No - it isn't weird. I had a similar reaction (though the boxing metaphor was a little contrived.) The odds really are against the Light; and winning isn't the same thing as survival - even if the Dark One is defeated, it might be at the cost of lives that are dear to us. As Jo reminded us, people die in wars and orphans are created. A complete victory with happy endings all around would strain our credulity.

Oh yes. Are any of you getting a feeling of deja vu? Like we haven't in the past gone into a book(s) where we knew characters we'd come to love were going to die . . .

On another note, I just noticed something I'd missed before. I hadn't realized that the people following Mat and Perrin were being drawn to their Tavereness just as they are drawn to Rand.

Posted by: Shard Sep 1 2009, 11:01 AM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Sep 1 2009, 10:49 AM) *
QUOTE(MysteryloverAnne @ Sep 1 2009, 06:49 AM) *
QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Sep 1 2009, 04:30 AM) *
QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Aug 31 2009, 06:46 AM) *
I thought we were starting to make progress, but the above quote is really discouraging!

Is it weird that I find it really exciting? That we really are about to come into that final round and it all comes down to how much heart our guys have.



No - it isn't weird. I had a similar reaction (though the boxing metaphor was a little contrived.) The odds really are against the Light; and winning isn't the same thing as survival - even if the Dark One is defeated, it might be at the cost of lives that are dear to us. As Jo reminded us, people die in wars and orphans are created. A complete victory with happy endings all around would strain our credulity.

Oh yes. Are any of you getting a feeling of deja vu? Like we haven't in the past gone into a book(s) where we knew characters we'd come to love were going to die . . .

On another note, I just noticed something I'd missed before. I hadn't realized that the people following Mat and Perrin were being drawn to their Tavereness just as they are drawn to Rand.



I don't know about the Boxing analogy being contrived maybe it's a poor comparison and I'm not sure if it was Jason, RJ or Brandon who originated it now.

From the perspective of RJ though I think he being a war veteran wouldn't give us an ending where all the good guys live and have a happy ending. I suspect that like Jo the real body count isn't coming until the end. No one knew the amount of death that we would get int Deathly Hallows and that is from an author who relativley speaking as far less experience with war then RJ. So I think we may be in for another round of tissues.

I think the Trio's Taverness has been so much so that even the Wondergirls are drawing people to them. It just felt that way when random AS start dropping to their knees before Eggy and swear alligance to HER and not just as the Amrylin Seat. It may also explain why Elayne keeps falling for stupid and obvious traps and somehow surviving them.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Sep 1 2009, 11:45 AM

QUOTE(Shard @ Sep 1 2009, 10:01 AM) *
I don't know about the Boxing analogy being contrived maybe it's a poor comparison and I'm not sure if it was Jason, RJ or Brandon who originated it now.

That was an RJ quote, according to the article.

QUOTE(Shard @ Sep 1 2009, 10:01 AM) *
I think the Trio's Taverness has been so much so that even the Wondergirls are drawing people to them. It just felt that way when random AS start dropping to their knees before Eggy and swear alligance to HER and not just as the Amrylin Seat. It may also explain why Elayne keeps falling for stupid and obvious traps and somehow surviving them.

Do the books ever mention female taverens?

Posted by: Shard Sep 1 2009, 10:14 PM

Well then I think it's his personal experience I've been told there's alot of boxing in the military branches especially Navy vs Army.

I think a better analogy is that the Light has a ton of supplies but half of it is corrupted or broken and the problem is they don't know which half it is and won't know until it's too late.

I don't think any have been mentioned but I'm sure it does happen.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Sep 2 2009, 01:25 PM

I'm wondering about Calandor. When Rand uses it against the Seanchan he ends up killing a bunch of his own people and is told that it's meant to be used by a man and a woman (I'm guessing Egwene when the time comes--unless it's Moiraine, which would make sense if she's to play such a vital role at the last battle). However, he used it to kill the bad guys in a rather spectacular way when they attacked the Stone in Tear. So what's the difference?

Posted by: Shard Sep 4 2009, 05:32 AM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Sep 2 2009, 02:25 PM) *
I'm wondering about Calandor. When Rand uses it against the Seanchan he ends up killing a bunch of his own people and is told that it's meant to be used by a man and a woman (I'm guessing Egwene when the time comes--unless it's Moiraine, which would make sense if she's to play such a vital role at the last battle). However, he used it to kill the bad guys in a rather spectacular way when they attacked the Stone in Tear. So what's the difference?


The difference is control, in the Tear he was in control or managing it enough so it wasn't destroying everything in sight. The second time around he starts shouting out "I am the Storm!" and blasting everything in sight. Davram was worried that he had snapped and everyone was going to die if he didn't stop Rand's mad channeling.

I think it's another sign from Jordan on just how bad Rand is degrading and falling apart.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Sep 5 2009, 05:02 PM

The first chapter is now available at http://www.dragonmount.com/News/. You'll have to join--it's free. Audio is available as well as the written word.

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Sep 5 2009, 05:54 PM

Nope....I hate getting a taste when I want the whole thing. dry.gif I will wait for the book to come out (and respectfully ask anyone who does want to discuss the chapter one peek to use spoiler tags.)

Posted by: Shard Sep 6 2009, 11:33 AM

It wasn't that spoilery honestly, I think it's more of showcasing Brandon's writing style for the rest of this series. It's a way of showing the fans what to expect.

That being said:

I really enjoyed it though there are parts or lines that are clearly Brandon, it's as they said that this would be Brandon's voice but in an Epic Jordan way. I feel that is exactly it, there's just something different. It's not bad but it's different and I think I would still notice had I not been told but I wouldn't make a huge deal about it.

I think we do get some good leads into what this book will be about now with mentioning Graendal, Asmo, Arad Domon, and even the sword Rand is now carrying.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Sep 7 2009, 10:36 AM

After I listened to the first chapter, I realized that I will need to go back and listen again the some of the end of KoD, because I'm not remembering some of the things being referred to. It sucks to get old!

Posted by: Shard Sep 7 2009, 04:19 PM

Your not the only one that does this, lots of people are re-reading. In fact Brandon is going to do a re-read himself of KoD when he begins WoT13 and he had read the entire series last year.

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Sep 7 2009, 05:16 PM

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Sep 8 2009, 03:36 AM) *
After I listened to the first chapter, I realized that I will need to go back and listen again the some of the end of KoD, because I'm not remembering some of the things being referred to. It sucks to get old!

I suspect it's not age but the amount of detail that is now in the books. There's just far too much to keep track of.

I was browsing through a friend's bookcase (as you do) and I found that she has a copy of Elantris which I have now borrowed. I'm looking forward to reading it to get that taste of the style. I'm still debating reading the chapter at Tor. I remember reading the first chapter of book 2 which was in the end of my book 1, and being grumpy that I couldn't have more yet.

Posted by: Shard Sep 9 2009, 07:49 AM

Have you read the chapter 7of9? Did you like it?

I can understand the chapter being a tease but I'm glad I read it it was really good insight into what's to come. Those who have read it are already exploding with discussion on it. Can't wait to see the talks when the whole thing is released.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Sep 10 2009, 01:18 PM

Actually, Shard, I listened to it, since that was an option on that site. I'm excited that the audiobook will be released at the same time as the hardback book. If anyone's been interested in hearing what they are like, you can get a little sampling from there. I will say that Michael Kramer (there are two readers) is the only one we hear in that chapter. He reads this one much slower than he has previous books, but I love his--he's fabulous.

As to the chapter, I'd forgotten that they captured a forsaken at the end of KoD. I guess I got so caught up in Rand losing his hand that I forgot about the other. I think it's funny that Cadsuane is getting frustrated that Rand won't let them torture Graendal.

Posted by: Shard Sep 11 2009, 06:22 PM

Yeah Audio books are an excellent way to listen to the books... I mean when you can't sit and just read the book it's cool to have an audio option.

Boy of all the details to forget about huh? lol

Apparently the Swords identity may have been confirmed now.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Sep 26 2009, 05:22 PM

Hmmmm . . . I was just listening to Chapter 2 of The Gathering Storm, and it's talking about Egwene's situation in the White Tower (no spoilers here as this is all information found in KoD). She was being given her regular dose of fork root tea, and it make me wonder about something. What happens when someone is given a small dose of it on a regular basis? Remember they are only giving her enough to damper her ability to channel and not to keep her from channeling at all. Could it be like some kinds of poison that can be ingested in small amounts so as to build up a resistance? ponder.gif

ETA
Wow, the realization Egwene comes to at the end of chapter 2 is rather pointedly similar to something Rand needs to learn. So could it be Egwene and not Cadsuane and Amis who will help Rand fix himself?

Posted by: Seven of Nine Oct 3 2009, 09:36 AM

What does the DO want with Rand? Not dead (he's had him saved twice). Does he want to turn him and have Rand help him take out the Creator?

Posted by: Shard Oct 5 2009, 11:19 AM

Well if the DO can turn Rand to the Dark Side I believe he feels that Rand will be able to fully release him from the prision. Rand is supposed to be the Champion of the light and if they can get him to betray that then it is the ultimate win. You see I think they are bluffing when they say "dead or alive we can use you" I think if he dies they CANNOT use him, at least not the way they want to.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Oct 5 2009, 12:58 PM

My son and I were talking about what the DO might want with Rand. My son suggested that Lews Therin, when he killed himself and created Dragonmount, did something unique. Normally if you draw too much power, you still yourself. I know sometimes people die, but does that come from drawing too much power? My son wonders if the DO thinks that by using a turned Rand it will give the DO a weapon to take on the Creator.

Posted by: Shard Oct 5 2009, 08:41 PM

I have a feeling that in all the turnings of the Wheel the DO has never turned The Dragon Soul aka Rand and Lews. I noticed that in the other times where Rand has died I asked myself why didn't the DO get free then? Like the worlds where Rand dies before even knowing his destiny and yet somehow the DO is still stuck. It would seem to me that the DO needs Rand alive and on HIS side to get out.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Oct 6 2009, 12:46 PM

Yes, that's what we were thinking. Even in those worlds where the DO one and trollics destroyed everything, the DO was still bound. So just killing Rand can't be the goal.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Oct 13 2009, 12:59 PM

Wow. I'd never heard of the body swap theory and was wondering everyone's take on it is. It has to do with Rand's balefire stream that crossed with Moridin's (we assume it was him) in Shador Logoth. Since that happened Rand's been having trouble with Saidin and it's like there's a third person in his head (like Lews Therin isn't enough, right?). And as time goes by, Rand is able to see this third person now--see what the person looks like.

It's being suggested that Min's viewing of Rand being two people and merging into one (that I'd always thought would be Lews) Therin) is actually about Rand and Moridin becoming one. blink.gif

Posted by: Shard Oct 16 2009, 01:35 PM

It's a theory that has been around for awhile, see this is why you needed to read the forums like Dragonmount. Though the same could be said for Harry Potter as well.

As for the theory I kinda feel the same way about the Harrycrux one, it's so strange I just don't know what to think. Personally I don't think Rand being put into Moridin's body sounds like a good idea. I mean Moridin's body is all addicted to the Saa now so I think I rather have the branded, rotting, one hand body thank you.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Oct 16 2009, 03:01 PM

Eeewwww. . . I'd completely forgotten about that. So that definitely wouldn't be a good thing for Rand. Just over a week now!

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Oct 27 2009, 02:09 PM

Got my copy on my doorstep this morning. I suspect I'll be reading alllll day biggrin.gif

Posted by: Seven of Nine Oct 27 2009, 02:58 PM

Ugh! I haven't got mine yet. I was hoping the audiobook would be available today, too, but I'm not seeing it yet. Grrrr!

ETA--It's up!!! I'll download it when I get home from work tonight!! excited.gif

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Oct 27 2009, 08:25 PM

QUOTE(Harrys Horntail @ Oct 27 2009, 02:09 PM) *
Got my copy on my doorstep this morning. I suspect I'll be reading alllll day biggrin.gif


I am jealous! Amazon says mine is on its way......*tapping foot impatiently* dry.gif

Posted by: Seven of Nine Nov 1 2009, 09:42 PM

Wow. All I can say is, "Wow." I've got to digest this a bit and then I'll comment.

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Nov 1 2009, 10:12 PM

sad.gif Mine still isn't here.....it is somewhere 'in transit' according to UPS tracking...I was supposed to have it Friday.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Nov 2 2009, 06:45 PM

I picked up my paper copy from Barnes & Noble during lunch today. I'm doing this one a little differently than I've always done the HP books. I would usually read the paper book and then listen to the audio. This time I listened to the audio, and now I'll read the book.

All I can say is Egwene rocks!

Posted by: Harrys Horntail Nov 2 2009, 07:04 PM

MLA: that really bites! I hope it gets to you really soon so you can read and enjoy hug.gif

QUOTE(Seven of Nine @ Nov 3 2009, 11:45 AM) *
All I can say is Egwene rocks!


She really does! I haven't read the whole thing yet, but so far she is definitely my favourite character. I'm not so fond of my real, sentimental favourite Perrin in this one so far, but I'm hoping with a (hopefully) bigger role and an author who has eased into the world he will return as the Perrin I love in the next two.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Nov 5 2009, 03:08 PM

Yes, the little bit of Perrin that we see is very angst ridden. I was surprised.

After I got my hard copy of the book, I went back and read the chapter with Rand's turning point. I really liked it, but I'm wondering how Cadsuane could claim any credit for helping Rand to learn anything. It seems more that Tam helped Rand do. The only credit Cadsuane can take, imho, is that she got Nynaeve to find out where Perrin was so someone could go and get Tam. Can I just say I love Tam? I want to learn more about him, and I want to see him interact more with Rand. I loved how he put Cadsuane in her place. devil.gif

Posted by: MysteryloverAnne Nov 5 2009, 10:43 PM

I agree with you, Seven of Nine, about Cadsuane - I distrust her more the more I see of her. I was a little disappointed that Mat and Thom didn't make it to the Tower of Genghi (spelling?) in this book.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Nov 6 2009, 02:39 PM

Well, with the next book being titled The Tower of Midnight I think we'll finally get that one resolved.

Posted by: Seven of Nine Nov 28 2009, 11:13 AM

I had a chance to ask Brandon some questions at a book signing last night. He said there is a hint in TGS about who killed Asmodean. I also asked about the 3 oaths and and they will really mean anything what with strong channelers among the Aiel Wise Ones (no oaths), Sea Folk Wind Finders (no oaths), and Seanchan Damani (no oaths). He commented a bit about how important the oaths are to the AS, but he wouldn't give any hints as to whether Egwene will change her mind about them.

Posted by: Shard Nov 30 2009, 05:27 AM

Bradon said that the title was also a reference to three Towers and he was even tempted to use that 'The Three Towers' as a title for homage to Tolkien.

Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)